Does it make sense to start saving into a 401k, if you might move out of the US before retirement?Should I open an RRSP if I don't plan to retire in Canada?If a non-citizen non-US-resident withdraws from their 401k, are they taxed based on their US income or worldwide income?Green Card holder (permanent resident): Should I contribute to my employer-matched 401(k), even if I might leave the U.S. later?Employer overpaid 401k - what's my liability?Over contribution to 401K between two employers, and maximizing employer match?Which earnings can be withdrawn when making an in-service withdrawal from a 401k?Could my employer give me a raise in terms of employer 401k contributions instead of salary?New 401(k) account, barely funded: can I withdraw penalty-free?What happens to the company match for a 401k over-contribution?Does 401k on H-1b visa make sense when there is an employer match?How to intentionally overcontribute to 401(k) to maximize new employer's matching?Two jobs two 401K both matches up to 6%
Better than Rembrandt
Was murdering a slave illegal in American slavery, and if so, what punishments were given for it?
Why should one apply for UK visa before other visas, on a multi-destination European holiday?
Character had a different name in the past. Which name should I use in a flashback?
Why could the Lunar Ascent Engine be used only once?
Should I twist DC power and ground wires from a power supply?
Why is so much ransomware breakable?
What should I wear to go and sign an employment contract?
Addressing an email
Have the writers and actors of Game Of Thrones responded to its poor reception?
Is my company merging branches wrong?
Isn't Kirchhoff's junction law a violation of conservation of charge?
How was the blinking terminal cursor invented?
How to make labels automatically scale in size to fit between 2 coordinates in tikz?
Can 2 light bulbs of 120V in series be used on 230V AC?
How do you cope with rejection?
Managing heat dissipation in a magic wand
Working hours and productivity expectations for game artists and programmers
Bash - Execute two commands and get exit status 1 if first fails
Find the 3D region containing the origin bounded by given planes
Can a Warforged have a ranged weapon affixed to them like an armblade?
Is being an extrovert a necessary condition to be a manager?
Why were early aviators' trousers flared at the thigh?
What were the "pills" that were added to solid waste in Apollo 7?
Does it make sense to start saving into a 401k, if you might move out of the US before retirement?
Should I open an RRSP if I don't plan to retire in Canada?If a non-citizen non-US-resident withdraws from their 401k, are they taxed based on their US income or worldwide income?Green Card holder (permanent resident): Should I contribute to my employer-matched 401(k), even if I might leave the U.S. later?Employer overpaid 401k - what's my liability?Over contribution to 401K between two employers, and maximizing employer match?Which earnings can be withdrawn when making an in-service withdrawal from a 401k?Could my employer give me a raise in terms of employer 401k contributions instead of salary?New 401(k) account, barely funded: can I withdraw penalty-free?What happens to the company match for a 401k over-contribution?Does 401k on H-1b visa make sense when there is an employer match?How to intentionally overcontribute to 401(k) to maximize new employer's matching?Two jobs two 401K both matches up to 6%
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
Contributions to 401k funds are subject to a 10% penalty if taken out before the age of 59.5. Presuming my employer has a 401k matching program, does it make sense to contribute to a 401k if I might move out of the US before the age of 59.5 and therefore take my savings with me to another country?
united-states 401k penalty moving employer-match
|
show 1 more comment
Contributions to 401k funds are subject to a 10% penalty if taken out before the age of 59.5. Presuming my employer has a 401k matching program, does it make sense to contribute to a 401k if I might move out of the US before the age of 59.5 and therefore take my savings with me to another country?
united-states 401k penalty moving employer-match
Related: money.stackexchange.com/questions/89968/…
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 17:58
Is the question from the point of view of a citizen of the US who plans to retire as an expat in the other country, or a non-US citizen?
– user662852
May 6 at 18:24
@user662852 non-US citizen
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 18:30
1
Is there something that prevents you from keeping your funds in your 401k even if you move out of the country? Then, just take it out when you turn 59.5?
– Better Budget
May 6 at 20:34
@BetterBudget lots of headache managing a fund in a foreign country, potentially
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 20:35
|
show 1 more comment
Contributions to 401k funds are subject to a 10% penalty if taken out before the age of 59.5. Presuming my employer has a 401k matching program, does it make sense to contribute to a 401k if I might move out of the US before the age of 59.5 and therefore take my savings with me to another country?
united-states 401k penalty moving employer-match
Contributions to 401k funds are subject to a 10% penalty if taken out before the age of 59.5. Presuming my employer has a 401k matching program, does it make sense to contribute to a 401k if I might move out of the US before the age of 59.5 and therefore take my savings with me to another country?
united-states 401k penalty moving employer-match
united-states 401k penalty moving employer-match
edited May 6 at 18:19
Chris W. Rea
26.8k1587175
26.8k1587175
asked May 6 at 17:58
JonathanReezJonathanReez
2,01051930
2,01051930
Related: money.stackexchange.com/questions/89968/…
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 17:58
Is the question from the point of view of a citizen of the US who plans to retire as an expat in the other country, or a non-US citizen?
– user662852
May 6 at 18:24
@user662852 non-US citizen
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 18:30
1
Is there something that prevents you from keeping your funds in your 401k even if you move out of the country? Then, just take it out when you turn 59.5?
– Better Budget
May 6 at 20:34
@BetterBudget lots of headache managing a fund in a foreign country, potentially
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 20:35
|
show 1 more comment
Related: money.stackexchange.com/questions/89968/…
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 17:58
Is the question from the point of view of a citizen of the US who plans to retire as an expat in the other country, or a non-US citizen?
– user662852
May 6 at 18:24
@user662852 non-US citizen
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 18:30
1
Is there something that prevents you from keeping your funds in your 401k even if you move out of the country? Then, just take it out when you turn 59.5?
– Better Budget
May 6 at 20:34
@BetterBudget lots of headache managing a fund in a foreign country, potentially
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 20:35
Related: money.stackexchange.com/questions/89968/…
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 17:58
Related: money.stackexchange.com/questions/89968/…
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 17:58
Is the question from the point of view of a citizen of the US who plans to retire as an expat in the other country, or a non-US citizen?
– user662852
May 6 at 18:24
Is the question from the point of view of a citizen of the US who plans to retire as an expat in the other country, or a non-US citizen?
– user662852
May 6 at 18:24
@user662852 non-US citizen
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 18:30
@user662852 non-US citizen
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 18:30
1
1
Is there something that prevents you from keeping your funds in your 401k even if you move out of the country? Then, just take it out when you turn 59.5?
– Better Budget
May 6 at 20:34
Is there something that prevents you from keeping your funds in your 401k even if you move out of the country? Then, just take it out when you turn 59.5?
– Better Budget
May 6 at 20:34
@BetterBudget lots of headache managing a fund in a foreign country, potentially
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 20:35
@BetterBudget lots of headache managing a fund in a foreign country, potentially
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 20:35
|
show 1 more comment
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
It does make sense to contribute to your 401k, even if you plan to move out of the country. Besides the "headache managing a fund in a foreign country", you can keep your 401k even if you're residing in a foreign country (source). Your best financial outcome would be to contribute to your 401k with matches and hold it until you're 59.5 and just figure out how to minimize the "headache".
3
This does depend on the country. Some will tax you on the yearly gains of the 401k anyway. Then you will be taxed again by the US during draw down.
– Vality
May 6 at 21:14
add a comment |
If it's a Roth 401k, you can withdraw what you invested (but not the growth) at any time, without penalty.
Then you just have to wait until you are 59.5 to withdraw any growth that occurred.
I do all my 401k management online, so I see no reason why that couldn't be done from a foreign country. If your company's 401k broker doesn't support that, you could roll the 401k over into an IRA held with a manager that does support online management. It may be worth asking potential fund managers how they would handle that now.
It's also worth thinking about the risks here.
- If you do not use the 401k and instead use an unrestricted investment vehicle, you are guaranteed worse tax treatment and no employer match if you stay long enough to retire.
- If you do not invest at all, then you are guaranteed not to get any investment returns nor any employer match.
- If you invest in the 401k, then at worst you pay a 10% penalty and the taxes that you avoided (if any).
My thought is that the last risk is less of a problem than the two previous risks. This is particularly so if you can just leave the money in the account until you are old enough to withdraw it. So I would invest in the 401k. But you know more about the likelihoods of the various options than I do. For example, if it's a definite plan to leave the United States in five years and you are in your twenties or thirties, it may not be worth the aggravation. If you're not sure if you're going to leave the US and are already in your fifties, that's a completely different situation.
add a comment |
Yes
Assuming it's a 50% match, your absolute worst case scenario is that you'll have to withdraw the money, pay taxes on the money and pay 10% penalty. However, you already avoided taxes on the income. So you're likely putting 20% or so more into the 401(k) than you would have received if you hadn't contributed.
Assuming you make it to the top marginal tax rate, including the penalty, you still spend less than 50% of the income on taxes, which makes it a net positive in any scenario.
The numbers look even better for a 100% match, obviously.
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "93"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: true,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: 10,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmoney.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f108661%2fdoes-it-make-sense-to-start-saving-into-a-401k-if-you-might-move-out-of-the-us%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
It does make sense to contribute to your 401k, even if you plan to move out of the country. Besides the "headache managing a fund in a foreign country", you can keep your 401k even if you're residing in a foreign country (source). Your best financial outcome would be to contribute to your 401k with matches and hold it until you're 59.5 and just figure out how to minimize the "headache".
3
This does depend on the country. Some will tax you on the yearly gains of the 401k anyway. Then you will be taxed again by the US during draw down.
– Vality
May 6 at 21:14
add a comment |
It does make sense to contribute to your 401k, even if you plan to move out of the country. Besides the "headache managing a fund in a foreign country", you can keep your 401k even if you're residing in a foreign country (source). Your best financial outcome would be to contribute to your 401k with matches and hold it until you're 59.5 and just figure out how to minimize the "headache".
3
This does depend on the country. Some will tax you on the yearly gains of the 401k anyway. Then you will be taxed again by the US during draw down.
– Vality
May 6 at 21:14
add a comment |
It does make sense to contribute to your 401k, even if you plan to move out of the country. Besides the "headache managing a fund in a foreign country", you can keep your 401k even if you're residing in a foreign country (source). Your best financial outcome would be to contribute to your 401k with matches and hold it until you're 59.5 and just figure out how to minimize the "headache".
It does make sense to contribute to your 401k, even if you plan to move out of the country. Besides the "headache managing a fund in a foreign country", you can keep your 401k even if you're residing in a foreign country (source). Your best financial outcome would be to contribute to your 401k with matches and hold it until you're 59.5 and just figure out how to minimize the "headache".
answered May 6 at 20:47
Better BudgetBetter Budget
43113
43113
3
This does depend on the country. Some will tax you on the yearly gains of the 401k anyway. Then you will be taxed again by the US during draw down.
– Vality
May 6 at 21:14
add a comment |
3
This does depend on the country. Some will tax you on the yearly gains of the 401k anyway. Then you will be taxed again by the US during draw down.
– Vality
May 6 at 21:14
3
3
This does depend on the country. Some will tax you on the yearly gains of the 401k anyway. Then you will be taxed again by the US during draw down.
– Vality
May 6 at 21:14
This does depend on the country. Some will tax you on the yearly gains of the 401k anyway. Then you will be taxed again by the US during draw down.
– Vality
May 6 at 21:14
add a comment |
If it's a Roth 401k, you can withdraw what you invested (but not the growth) at any time, without penalty.
Then you just have to wait until you are 59.5 to withdraw any growth that occurred.
I do all my 401k management online, so I see no reason why that couldn't be done from a foreign country. If your company's 401k broker doesn't support that, you could roll the 401k over into an IRA held with a manager that does support online management. It may be worth asking potential fund managers how they would handle that now.
It's also worth thinking about the risks here.
- If you do not use the 401k and instead use an unrestricted investment vehicle, you are guaranteed worse tax treatment and no employer match if you stay long enough to retire.
- If you do not invest at all, then you are guaranteed not to get any investment returns nor any employer match.
- If you invest in the 401k, then at worst you pay a 10% penalty and the taxes that you avoided (if any).
My thought is that the last risk is less of a problem than the two previous risks. This is particularly so if you can just leave the money in the account until you are old enough to withdraw it. So I would invest in the 401k. But you know more about the likelihoods of the various options than I do. For example, if it's a definite plan to leave the United States in five years and you are in your twenties or thirties, it may not be worth the aggravation. If you're not sure if you're going to leave the US and are already in your fifties, that's a completely different situation.
add a comment |
If it's a Roth 401k, you can withdraw what you invested (but not the growth) at any time, without penalty.
Then you just have to wait until you are 59.5 to withdraw any growth that occurred.
I do all my 401k management online, so I see no reason why that couldn't be done from a foreign country. If your company's 401k broker doesn't support that, you could roll the 401k over into an IRA held with a manager that does support online management. It may be worth asking potential fund managers how they would handle that now.
It's also worth thinking about the risks here.
- If you do not use the 401k and instead use an unrestricted investment vehicle, you are guaranteed worse tax treatment and no employer match if you stay long enough to retire.
- If you do not invest at all, then you are guaranteed not to get any investment returns nor any employer match.
- If you invest in the 401k, then at worst you pay a 10% penalty and the taxes that you avoided (if any).
My thought is that the last risk is less of a problem than the two previous risks. This is particularly so if you can just leave the money in the account until you are old enough to withdraw it. So I would invest in the 401k. But you know more about the likelihoods of the various options than I do. For example, if it's a definite plan to leave the United States in five years and you are in your twenties or thirties, it may not be worth the aggravation. If you're not sure if you're going to leave the US and are already in your fifties, that's a completely different situation.
add a comment |
If it's a Roth 401k, you can withdraw what you invested (but not the growth) at any time, without penalty.
Then you just have to wait until you are 59.5 to withdraw any growth that occurred.
I do all my 401k management online, so I see no reason why that couldn't be done from a foreign country. If your company's 401k broker doesn't support that, you could roll the 401k over into an IRA held with a manager that does support online management. It may be worth asking potential fund managers how they would handle that now.
It's also worth thinking about the risks here.
- If you do not use the 401k and instead use an unrestricted investment vehicle, you are guaranteed worse tax treatment and no employer match if you stay long enough to retire.
- If you do not invest at all, then you are guaranteed not to get any investment returns nor any employer match.
- If you invest in the 401k, then at worst you pay a 10% penalty and the taxes that you avoided (if any).
My thought is that the last risk is less of a problem than the two previous risks. This is particularly so if you can just leave the money in the account until you are old enough to withdraw it. So I would invest in the 401k. But you know more about the likelihoods of the various options than I do. For example, if it's a definite plan to leave the United States in five years and you are in your twenties or thirties, it may not be worth the aggravation. If you're not sure if you're going to leave the US and are already in your fifties, that's a completely different situation.
If it's a Roth 401k, you can withdraw what you invested (but not the growth) at any time, without penalty.
Then you just have to wait until you are 59.5 to withdraw any growth that occurred.
I do all my 401k management online, so I see no reason why that couldn't be done from a foreign country. If your company's 401k broker doesn't support that, you could roll the 401k over into an IRA held with a manager that does support online management. It may be worth asking potential fund managers how they would handle that now.
It's also worth thinking about the risks here.
- If you do not use the 401k and instead use an unrestricted investment vehicle, you are guaranteed worse tax treatment and no employer match if you stay long enough to retire.
- If you do not invest at all, then you are guaranteed not to get any investment returns nor any employer match.
- If you invest in the 401k, then at worst you pay a 10% penalty and the taxes that you avoided (if any).
My thought is that the last risk is less of a problem than the two previous risks. This is particularly so if you can just leave the money in the account until you are old enough to withdraw it. So I would invest in the 401k. But you know more about the likelihoods of the various options than I do. For example, if it's a definite plan to leave the United States in five years and you are in your twenties or thirties, it may not be worth the aggravation. If you're not sure if you're going to leave the US and are already in your fifties, that's a completely different situation.
answered May 7 at 5:23
BrythanBrythan
19.3k64362
19.3k64362
add a comment |
add a comment |
Yes
Assuming it's a 50% match, your absolute worst case scenario is that you'll have to withdraw the money, pay taxes on the money and pay 10% penalty. However, you already avoided taxes on the income. So you're likely putting 20% or so more into the 401(k) than you would have received if you hadn't contributed.
Assuming you make it to the top marginal tax rate, including the penalty, you still spend less than 50% of the income on taxes, which makes it a net positive in any scenario.
The numbers look even better for a 100% match, obviously.
add a comment |
Yes
Assuming it's a 50% match, your absolute worst case scenario is that you'll have to withdraw the money, pay taxes on the money and pay 10% penalty. However, you already avoided taxes on the income. So you're likely putting 20% or so more into the 401(k) than you would have received if you hadn't contributed.
Assuming you make it to the top marginal tax rate, including the penalty, you still spend less than 50% of the income on taxes, which makes it a net positive in any scenario.
The numbers look even better for a 100% match, obviously.
add a comment |
Yes
Assuming it's a 50% match, your absolute worst case scenario is that you'll have to withdraw the money, pay taxes on the money and pay 10% penalty. However, you already avoided taxes on the income. So you're likely putting 20% or so more into the 401(k) than you would have received if you hadn't contributed.
Assuming you make it to the top marginal tax rate, including the penalty, you still spend less than 50% of the income on taxes, which makes it a net positive in any scenario.
The numbers look even better for a 100% match, obviously.
Yes
Assuming it's a 50% match, your absolute worst case scenario is that you'll have to withdraw the money, pay taxes on the money and pay 10% penalty. However, you already avoided taxes on the income. So you're likely putting 20% or so more into the 401(k) than you would have received if you hadn't contributed.
Assuming you make it to the top marginal tax rate, including the penalty, you still spend less than 50% of the income on taxes, which makes it a net positive in any scenario.
The numbers look even better for a 100% match, obviously.
answered May 7 at 15:31
xyiousxyious
1,390314
1,390314
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Personal Finance & Money Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmoney.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f108661%2fdoes-it-make-sense-to-start-saving-into-a-401k-if-you-might-move-out-of-the-us%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Related: money.stackexchange.com/questions/89968/…
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 17:58
Is the question from the point of view of a citizen of the US who plans to retire as an expat in the other country, or a non-US citizen?
– user662852
May 6 at 18:24
@user662852 non-US citizen
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 18:30
1
Is there something that prevents you from keeping your funds in your 401k even if you move out of the country? Then, just take it out when you turn 59.5?
– Better Budget
May 6 at 20:34
@BetterBudget lots of headache managing a fund in a foreign country, potentially
– JonathanReez
May 6 at 20:35