Is counterpoint still used today?Is there any name for two melodies that are being played at the same time?Is there some trick for counterpoint beyond 2 voices?Resources for “popular” counterpoint?Simple explanation of counterpoint?When did the half-step/whole-step modulation in the middle of a song become popular?Is it true that Mozart would pale in comparison to child prodigies today?What determines if counterpoint is good or bad?Was alto in the past lower in pitch than where they are today?How to write in counterpoint for a sonata?How to apply counterpoint to my own compositions?Bach's Toccata and Fugue in D minor breaks the “no parallel octaves” rule?
Similarity score: Can Sklearn SVR predict values greater than 1 and less than 0?
career in signal processing
Prime sieve in Python
Constitutionality of U.S. Democratic Presidential Candidate's Supreme Court Suggestion
Why does using different ArrayList constructors cause a different growth rate of the internal array?
Does a vocal melody have any rhythmic responsibility to the underlying arrangement in pop music?
LWC - Local Dev - How can I run the local server on HTTPS?
Can Ogre clerics use Purify Food and Drink on humanoid characters?
What does it mean to not be able to take the derivative of a function multiple times?
Do I have any obligations to my PhD supervisor's requests after I have graduated?
Trainee keeps passing deadlines for independent learning
Why does the Saturn V have standalone inter-stage rings?
Does the monk's Step of the Wind feature activate the benefit of the Mobile feat?
Understanding the reasoning of the woman who agreed with Shlomo to "cut the baby in half"
What can I do with a research project that is my university’s intellectual property?
Will generated tokens be progressively stronger when using Cathar's Crusade and Sorin, Grim Nemesis?
Did the CIA blow up a Siberian pipeline in 1982?
Helping ease my back pain by studying 13 hours everyday , even weekends
Story about hunting giant lizards for hides on privately owned planet
Is there any difference between Т34ВМ1 and КМ1858ВМ1/3?
How do I farm creepers for XP without them exploding?
"Correct me if I'm wrong"
Is there a term for the belief that "if it's legal, it's moral"?
Designing a magic-compatible polearm
Is counterpoint still used today?
Is there any name for two melodies that are being played at the same time?Is there some trick for counterpoint beyond 2 voices?Resources for “popular” counterpoint?Simple explanation of counterpoint?When did the half-step/whole-step modulation in the middle of a song become popular?Is it true that Mozart would pale in comparison to child prodigies today?What determines if counterpoint is good or bad?Was alto in the past lower in pitch than where they are today?How to write in counterpoint for a sonata?How to apply counterpoint to my own compositions?Bach's Toccata and Fugue in D minor breaks the “no parallel octaves” rule?
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
I was wondering if counterpoint is still used today or was it something that was just used by Bach? Does modern music like pop songs use it?
history counterpoint
add a comment |
I was wondering if counterpoint is still used today or was it something that was just used by Bach? Does modern music like pop songs use it?
history counterpoint
3
A shame that some feel the need to bash any post that in any way questions common practice harmony. +1.
– user45266
Jun 4 at 1:48
4
It's used a lot in popular music. Usually a line is sung by a lead vocalist then repeated by others with a varied melody. Here's some in the opening number of the musical Hamilton youtu.be/VhinPd5RRJw?t=166
– AJFaraday
Jun 4 at 8:18
I've heard this club/dance song incorporates counterpoint. youtu.be/WP47nuuOU_I (Reference: edmtunes.com/2014/05/look-mom-told-featuring-andrew-bayer)
– Wireblue
Jun 5 at 2:32
add a comment |
I was wondering if counterpoint is still used today or was it something that was just used by Bach? Does modern music like pop songs use it?
history counterpoint
I was wondering if counterpoint is still used today or was it something that was just used by Bach? Does modern music like pop songs use it?
history counterpoint
history counterpoint
edited Jun 4 at 10:17
foreyez
asked Jun 3 at 21:30
foreyezforeyez
5,94152793
5,94152793
3
A shame that some feel the need to bash any post that in any way questions common practice harmony. +1.
– user45266
Jun 4 at 1:48
4
It's used a lot in popular music. Usually a line is sung by a lead vocalist then repeated by others with a varied melody. Here's some in the opening number of the musical Hamilton youtu.be/VhinPd5RRJw?t=166
– AJFaraday
Jun 4 at 8:18
I've heard this club/dance song incorporates counterpoint. youtu.be/WP47nuuOU_I (Reference: edmtunes.com/2014/05/look-mom-told-featuring-andrew-bayer)
– Wireblue
Jun 5 at 2:32
add a comment |
3
A shame that some feel the need to bash any post that in any way questions common practice harmony. +1.
– user45266
Jun 4 at 1:48
4
It's used a lot in popular music. Usually a line is sung by a lead vocalist then repeated by others with a varied melody. Here's some in the opening number of the musical Hamilton youtu.be/VhinPd5RRJw?t=166
– AJFaraday
Jun 4 at 8:18
I've heard this club/dance song incorporates counterpoint. youtu.be/WP47nuuOU_I (Reference: edmtunes.com/2014/05/look-mom-told-featuring-andrew-bayer)
– Wireblue
Jun 5 at 2:32
3
3
A shame that some feel the need to bash any post that in any way questions common practice harmony. +1.
– user45266
Jun 4 at 1:48
A shame that some feel the need to bash any post that in any way questions common practice harmony. +1.
– user45266
Jun 4 at 1:48
4
4
It's used a lot in popular music. Usually a line is sung by a lead vocalist then repeated by others with a varied melody. Here's some in the opening number of the musical Hamilton youtu.be/VhinPd5RRJw?t=166
– AJFaraday
Jun 4 at 8:18
It's used a lot in popular music. Usually a line is sung by a lead vocalist then repeated by others with a varied melody. Here's some in the opening number of the musical Hamilton youtu.be/VhinPd5RRJw?t=166
– AJFaraday
Jun 4 at 8:18
I've heard this club/dance song incorporates counterpoint. youtu.be/WP47nuuOU_I (Reference: edmtunes.com/2014/05/look-mom-told-featuring-andrew-bayer)
– Wireblue
Jun 5 at 2:32
I've heard this club/dance song incorporates counterpoint. youtu.be/WP47nuuOU_I (Reference: edmtunes.com/2014/05/look-mom-told-featuring-andrew-bayer)
– Wireblue
Jun 5 at 2:32
add a comment |
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
Counterpoint is simply the relationship between multiple musical lines. As such, any excerpt of music with more than one line is displaying some sense of counterpoint, whether intentional or not.
Note also that there are multiple eras and traditions of counterpoint, each with their own distinct styles (what many erroneously call "rules"). Palestrina is typically considered the master of Renaissance counterpoint, with Bach being the master of Baroque counterpoint. Mozart and Beethoven were among the many masters of counterpoint in the Classical era, and getting into the Romantic era you have composers like Brahms and Bruckner. And in the twentieth century you have composers like Shostakovich and Hindemith, both of whom wrote sets of piano fugues much like Bach did.
If you're asking whether or not something like fugues are still written today, of course they are! In fact, the fugue at the end of Young Person's Guide to the Orchestra (1945) is still to this day one of the most impressive feats of counterpoint I know:
1
If counterpoint is the relationship between multiple music lines then most music would have some form of counterpoint, even any kind of pop song? or does melody+chords not count?
– foreyez
Jun 4 at 10:13
Indeed, composing a fugue is a key part of most (upper secondary) formal music education.
– OrangeDog
Jun 4 at 10:16
1
@foreyez Yes; you could look at, for instance, the counterpoint between the bass and melody.
– Richard
Jun 4 at 16:15
I feel that your definition is rather ample. If we add this qualification from Wikipedia : "Counterpoint focuses on melodic interaction—only secondarily on the harmonies produced by that interaction", I'd say that counterpoint is practically absent in modern popular music. We compose (and hear) "vertically" (structure defined by sequences of chords ), the melodic line(s) lie on top of that.
– leonbloy
Jun 5 at 2:13
2
The fugue in Young Person's Guide is truly fantastic but 1945 is "today"?
– David Richerby
Jun 5 at 12:04
|
show 1 more comment
One practical use in pop, country, big band, (and probably jazz, maybe rock) is the counterpoint between melody and bass. One would like the melody and bass to be independent voices. Many bass players use chord inversions (playing the third usually) and walking basses to achieve this (and they do it on the fly.) If one isn't careful about parallels, the texture can suddenly seem "thin" like an instrument dropped out.
I like to think of songs as being a melody line (maybe several instruments), a bass line (using good two-part counterpoint), and a bunch of inner stuff that need not be so careful (because of doublings and texture, one doesn't usually hear multiple lines in these styles). Renaissance counterpoint sounds more like several independent voices but Baroque counterpoint (not counting fugues, canons, and inventions) can be a bass line supporting upper voices with some filler for chords.
I'd like to add an example. I'm suggesting that even popular music (since the Middle Ages anyway) has a skeleton consisting of a bass line and a melody line (or lines) with some chords thrown in between and a related but separate percussion part. Here's an example of a song with just a bass and melody exhibiting the point.
add a comment |
It is still used, but not the way Bach used it. Bach used to compose the different voices to be harmonically interdependent but rhythmically independent. After a certain point (later 19th-early 20th century) the composers took counterpoint in a different direction. They started composing for voices that were purely independent with each other; both harmonically and rhythmically.
A great example is Arnold Schoenberg and his use of 12-tone serialism.
Here is a more modern piece that uses contrapuntal techniques:
Also, here is an example from Radiohead's In a glass house:
Notice how the horns move independently from the voice and the rhythm section and how the clarinet moves in a different rhythm that the brass.
add a comment |
I get the feeling the question is more along the lines of: is there counterpoint in homophonic music, or is a homophonic bass part a contrapuntal line?
I think the answer is yes to both.
It's very common in pop/rock for the bass to move only by leaps to roots while the vocal melody moves in a more step-wise manner. By necessity those two lines are independent in terms of contour and relative motion. And, in pop/rock it would be very common for the bass and voice to be rhythmically independent.
Independent contours, independent rhythms: how is that not counterpoint?
The discussion on this post... Is there any name for two melodies that are being played at the same time? ...still sticks in my mind as making a muddle out of a simple idea: independence of contour and rhythm makes counterpoint.
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "240"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmusic.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f85511%2fis-counterpoint-still-used-today%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
4 Answers
4
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
Counterpoint is simply the relationship between multiple musical lines. As such, any excerpt of music with more than one line is displaying some sense of counterpoint, whether intentional or not.
Note also that there are multiple eras and traditions of counterpoint, each with their own distinct styles (what many erroneously call "rules"). Palestrina is typically considered the master of Renaissance counterpoint, with Bach being the master of Baroque counterpoint. Mozart and Beethoven were among the many masters of counterpoint in the Classical era, and getting into the Romantic era you have composers like Brahms and Bruckner. And in the twentieth century you have composers like Shostakovich and Hindemith, both of whom wrote sets of piano fugues much like Bach did.
If you're asking whether or not something like fugues are still written today, of course they are! In fact, the fugue at the end of Young Person's Guide to the Orchestra (1945) is still to this day one of the most impressive feats of counterpoint I know:
1
If counterpoint is the relationship between multiple music lines then most music would have some form of counterpoint, even any kind of pop song? or does melody+chords not count?
– foreyez
Jun 4 at 10:13
Indeed, composing a fugue is a key part of most (upper secondary) formal music education.
– OrangeDog
Jun 4 at 10:16
1
@foreyez Yes; you could look at, for instance, the counterpoint between the bass and melody.
– Richard
Jun 4 at 16:15
I feel that your definition is rather ample. If we add this qualification from Wikipedia : "Counterpoint focuses on melodic interaction—only secondarily on the harmonies produced by that interaction", I'd say that counterpoint is practically absent in modern popular music. We compose (and hear) "vertically" (structure defined by sequences of chords ), the melodic line(s) lie on top of that.
– leonbloy
Jun 5 at 2:13
2
The fugue in Young Person's Guide is truly fantastic but 1945 is "today"?
– David Richerby
Jun 5 at 12:04
|
show 1 more comment
Counterpoint is simply the relationship between multiple musical lines. As such, any excerpt of music with more than one line is displaying some sense of counterpoint, whether intentional or not.
Note also that there are multiple eras and traditions of counterpoint, each with their own distinct styles (what many erroneously call "rules"). Palestrina is typically considered the master of Renaissance counterpoint, with Bach being the master of Baroque counterpoint. Mozart and Beethoven were among the many masters of counterpoint in the Classical era, and getting into the Romantic era you have composers like Brahms and Bruckner. And in the twentieth century you have composers like Shostakovich and Hindemith, both of whom wrote sets of piano fugues much like Bach did.
If you're asking whether or not something like fugues are still written today, of course they are! In fact, the fugue at the end of Young Person's Guide to the Orchestra (1945) is still to this day one of the most impressive feats of counterpoint I know:
1
If counterpoint is the relationship between multiple music lines then most music would have some form of counterpoint, even any kind of pop song? or does melody+chords not count?
– foreyez
Jun 4 at 10:13
Indeed, composing a fugue is a key part of most (upper secondary) formal music education.
– OrangeDog
Jun 4 at 10:16
1
@foreyez Yes; you could look at, for instance, the counterpoint between the bass and melody.
– Richard
Jun 4 at 16:15
I feel that your definition is rather ample. If we add this qualification from Wikipedia : "Counterpoint focuses on melodic interaction—only secondarily on the harmonies produced by that interaction", I'd say that counterpoint is practically absent in modern popular music. We compose (and hear) "vertically" (structure defined by sequences of chords ), the melodic line(s) lie on top of that.
– leonbloy
Jun 5 at 2:13
2
The fugue in Young Person's Guide is truly fantastic but 1945 is "today"?
– David Richerby
Jun 5 at 12:04
|
show 1 more comment
Counterpoint is simply the relationship between multiple musical lines. As such, any excerpt of music with more than one line is displaying some sense of counterpoint, whether intentional or not.
Note also that there are multiple eras and traditions of counterpoint, each with their own distinct styles (what many erroneously call "rules"). Palestrina is typically considered the master of Renaissance counterpoint, with Bach being the master of Baroque counterpoint. Mozart and Beethoven were among the many masters of counterpoint in the Classical era, and getting into the Romantic era you have composers like Brahms and Bruckner. And in the twentieth century you have composers like Shostakovich and Hindemith, both of whom wrote sets of piano fugues much like Bach did.
If you're asking whether or not something like fugues are still written today, of course they are! In fact, the fugue at the end of Young Person's Guide to the Orchestra (1945) is still to this day one of the most impressive feats of counterpoint I know:
Counterpoint is simply the relationship between multiple musical lines. As such, any excerpt of music with more than one line is displaying some sense of counterpoint, whether intentional or not.
Note also that there are multiple eras and traditions of counterpoint, each with their own distinct styles (what many erroneously call "rules"). Palestrina is typically considered the master of Renaissance counterpoint, with Bach being the master of Baroque counterpoint. Mozart and Beethoven were among the many masters of counterpoint in the Classical era, and getting into the Romantic era you have composers like Brahms and Bruckner. And in the twentieth century you have composers like Shostakovich and Hindemith, both of whom wrote sets of piano fugues much like Bach did.
If you're asking whether or not something like fugues are still written today, of course they are! In fact, the fugue at the end of Young Person's Guide to the Orchestra (1945) is still to this day one of the most impressive feats of counterpoint I know:
answered Jun 3 at 21:38
RichardRichard
48.3k8118205
48.3k8118205
1
If counterpoint is the relationship between multiple music lines then most music would have some form of counterpoint, even any kind of pop song? or does melody+chords not count?
– foreyez
Jun 4 at 10:13
Indeed, composing a fugue is a key part of most (upper secondary) formal music education.
– OrangeDog
Jun 4 at 10:16
1
@foreyez Yes; you could look at, for instance, the counterpoint between the bass and melody.
– Richard
Jun 4 at 16:15
I feel that your definition is rather ample. If we add this qualification from Wikipedia : "Counterpoint focuses on melodic interaction—only secondarily on the harmonies produced by that interaction", I'd say that counterpoint is practically absent in modern popular music. We compose (and hear) "vertically" (structure defined by sequences of chords ), the melodic line(s) lie on top of that.
– leonbloy
Jun 5 at 2:13
2
The fugue in Young Person's Guide is truly fantastic but 1945 is "today"?
– David Richerby
Jun 5 at 12:04
|
show 1 more comment
1
If counterpoint is the relationship between multiple music lines then most music would have some form of counterpoint, even any kind of pop song? or does melody+chords not count?
– foreyez
Jun 4 at 10:13
Indeed, composing a fugue is a key part of most (upper secondary) formal music education.
– OrangeDog
Jun 4 at 10:16
1
@foreyez Yes; you could look at, for instance, the counterpoint between the bass and melody.
– Richard
Jun 4 at 16:15
I feel that your definition is rather ample. If we add this qualification from Wikipedia : "Counterpoint focuses on melodic interaction—only secondarily on the harmonies produced by that interaction", I'd say that counterpoint is practically absent in modern popular music. We compose (and hear) "vertically" (structure defined by sequences of chords ), the melodic line(s) lie on top of that.
– leonbloy
Jun 5 at 2:13
2
The fugue in Young Person's Guide is truly fantastic but 1945 is "today"?
– David Richerby
Jun 5 at 12:04
1
1
If counterpoint is the relationship between multiple music lines then most music would have some form of counterpoint, even any kind of pop song? or does melody+chords not count?
– foreyez
Jun 4 at 10:13
If counterpoint is the relationship between multiple music lines then most music would have some form of counterpoint, even any kind of pop song? or does melody+chords not count?
– foreyez
Jun 4 at 10:13
Indeed, composing a fugue is a key part of most (upper secondary) formal music education.
– OrangeDog
Jun 4 at 10:16
Indeed, composing a fugue is a key part of most (upper secondary) formal music education.
– OrangeDog
Jun 4 at 10:16
1
1
@foreyez Yes; you could look at, for instance, the counterpoint between the bass and melody.
– Richard
Jun 4 at 16:15
@foreyez Yes; you could look at, for instance, the counterpoint between the bass and melody.
– Richard
Jun 4 at 16:15
I feel that your definition is rather ample. If we add this qualification from Wikipedia : "Counterpoint focuses on melodic interaction—only secondarily on the harmonies produced by that interaction", I'd say that counterpoint is practically absent in modern popular music. We compose (and hear) "vertically" (structure defined by sequences of chords ), the melodic line(s) lie on top of that.
– leonbloy
Jun 5 at 2:13
I feel that your definition is rather ample. If we add this qualification from Wikipedia : "Counterpoint focuses on melodic interaction—only secondarily on the harmonies produced by that interaction", I'd say that counterpoint is practically absent in modern popular music. We compose (and hear) "vertically" (structure defined by sequences of chords ), the melodic line(s) lie on top of that.
– leonbloy
Jun 5 at 2:13
2
2
The fugue in Young Person's Guide is truly fantastic but 1945 is "today"?
– David Richerby
Jun 5 at 12:04
The fugue in Young Person's Guide is truly fantastic but 1945 is "today"?
– David Richerby
Jun 5 at 12:04
|
show 1 more comment
One practical use in pop, country, big band, (and probably jazz, maybe rock) is the counterpoint between melody and bass. One would like the melody and bass to be independent voices. Many bass players use chord inversions (playing the third usually) and walking basses to achieve this (and they do it on the fly.) If one isn't careful about parallels, the texture can suddenly seem "thin" like an instrument dropped out.
I like to think of songs as being a melody line (maybe several instruments), a bass line (using good two-part counterpoint), and a bunch of inner stuff that need not be so careful (because of doublings and texture, one doesn't usually hear multiple lines in these styles). Renaissance counterpoint sounds more like several independent voices but Baroque counterpoint (not counting fugues, canons, and inventions) can be a bass line supporting upper voices with some filler for chords.
I'd like to add an example. I'm suggesting that even popular music (since the Middle Ages anyway) has a skeleton consisting of a bass line and a melody line (or lines) with some chords thrown in between and a related but separate percussion part. Here's an example of a song with just a bass and melody exhibiting the point.
add a comment |
One practical use in pop, country, big band, (and probably jazz, maybe rock) is the counterpoint between melody and bass. One would like the melody and bass to be independent voices. Many bass players use chord inversions (playing the third usually) and walking basses to achieve this (and they do it on the fly.) If one isn't careful about parallels, the texture can suddenly seem "thin" like an instrument dropped out.
I like to think of songs as being a melody line (maybe several instruments), a bass line (using good two-part counterpoint), and a bunch of inner stuff that need not be so careful (because of doublings and texture, one doesn't usually hear multiple lines in these styles). Renaissance counterpoint sounds more like several independent voices but Baroque counterpoint (not counting fugues, canons, and inventions) can be a bass line supporting upper voices with some filler for chords.
I'd like to add an example. I'm suggesting that even popular music (since the Middle Ages anyway) has a skeleton consisting of a bass line and a melody line (or lines) with some chords thrown in between and a related but separate percussion part. Here's an example of a song with just a bass and melody exhibiting the point.
add a comment |
One practical use in pop, country, big band, (and probably jazz, maybe rock) is the counterpoint between melody and bass. One would like the melody and bass to be independent voices. Many bass players use chord inversions (playing the third usually) and walking basses to achieve this (and they do it on the fly.) If one isn't careful about parallels, the texture can suddenly seem "thin" like an instrument dropped out.
I like to think of songs as being a melody line (maybe several instruments), a bass line (using good two-part counterpoint), and a bunch of inner stuff that need not be so careful (because of doublings and texture, one doesn't usually hear multiple lines in these styles). Renaissance counterpoint sounds more like several independent voices but Baroque counterpoint (not counting fugues, canons, and inventions) can be a bass line supporting upper voices with some filler for chords.
I'd like to add an example. I'm suggesting that even popular music (since the Middle Ages anyway) has a skeleton consisting of a bass line and a melody line (or lines) with some chords thrown in between and a related but separate percussion part. Here's an example of a song with just a bass and melody exhibiting the point.
One practical use in pop, country, big band, (and probably jazz, maybe rock) is the counterpoint between melody and bass. One would like the melody and bass to be independent voices. Many bass players use chord inversions (playing the third usually) and walking basses to achieve this (and they do it on the fly.) If one isn't careful about parallels, the texture can suddenly seem "thin" like an instrument dropped out.
I like to think of songs as being a melody line (maybe several instruments), a bass line (using good two-part counterpoint), and a bunch of inner stuff that need not be so careful (because of doublings and texture, one doesn't usually hear multiple lines in these styles). Renaissance counterpoint sounds more like several independent voices but Baroque counterpoint (not counting fugues, canons, and inventions) can be a bass line supporting upper voices with some filler for chords.
I'd like to add an example. I'm suggesting that even popular music (since the Middle Ages anyway) has a skeleton consisting of a bass line and a melody line (or lines) with some chords thrown in between and a related but separate percussion part. Here's an example of a song with just a bass and melody exhibiting the point.
edited Jun 5 at 18:45
answered Jun 3 at 22:03
ttwttw
10.1k1037
10.1k1037
add a comment |
add a comment |
It is still used, but not the way Bach used it. Bach used to compose the different voices to be harmonically interdependent but rhythmically independent. After a certain point (later 19th-early 20th century) the composers took counterpoint in a different direction. They started composing for voices that were purely independent with each other; both harmonically and rhythmically.
A great example is Arnold Schoenberg and his use of 12-tone serialism.
Here is a more modern piece that uses contrapuntal techniques:
Also, here is an example from Radiohead's In a glass house:
Notice how the horns move independently from the voice and the rhythm section and how the clarinet moves in a different rhythm that the brass.
add a comment |
It is still used, but not the way Bach used it. Bach used to compose the different voices to be harmonically interdependent but rhythmically independent. After a certain point (later 19th-early 20th century) the composers took counterpoint in a different direction. They started composing for voices that were purely independent with each other; both harmonically and rhythmically.
A great example is Arnold Schoenberg and his use of 12-tone serialism.
Here is a more modern piece that uses contrapuntal techniques:
Also, here is an example from Radiohead's In a glass house:
Notice how the horns move independently from the voice and the rhythm section and how the clarinet moves in a different rhythm that the brass.
add a comment |
It is still used, but not the way Bach used it. Bach used to compose the different voices to be harmonically interdependent but rhythmically independent. After a certain point (later 19th-early 20th century) the composers took counterpoint in a different direction. They started composing for voices that were purely independent with each other; both harmonically and rhythmically.
A great example is Arnold Schoenberg and his use of 12-tone serialism.
Here is a more modern piece that uses contrapuntal techniques:
Also, here is an example from Radiohead's In a glass house:
Notice how the horns move independently from the voice and the rhythm section and how the clarinet moves in a different rhythm that the brass.
It is still used, but not the way Bach used it. Bach used to compose the different voices to be harmonically interdependent but rhythmically independent. After a certain point (later 19th-early 20th century) the composers took counterpoint in a different direction. They started composing for voices that were purely independent with each other; both harmonically and rhythmically.
A great example is Arnold Schoenberg and his use of 12-tone serialism.
Here is a more modern piece that uses contrapuntal techniques:
Also, here is an example from Radiohead's In a glass house:
Notice how the horns move independently from the voice and the rhythm section and how the clarinet moves in a different rhythm that the brass.
edited Jun 3 at 21:48
answered Jun 3 at 21:41
ShevliaskovicShevliaskovic
22.8k1584182
22.8k1584182
add a comment |
add a comment |
I get the feeling the question is more along the lines of: is there counterpoint in homophonic music, or is a homophonic bass part a contrapuntal line?
I think the answer is yes to both.
It's very common in pop/rock for the bass to move only by leaps to roots while the vocal melody moves in a more step-wise manner. By necessity those two lines are independent in terms of contour and relative motion. And, in pop/rock it would be very common for the bass and voice to be rhythmically independent.
Independent contours, independent rhythms: how is that not counterpoint?
The discussion on this post... Is there any name for two melodies that are being played at the same time? ...still sticks in my mind as making a muddle out of a simple idea: independence of contour and rhythm makes counterpoint.
add a comment |
I get the feeling the question is more along the lines of: is there counterpoint in homophonic music, or is a homophonic bass part a contrapuntal line?
I think the answer is yes to both.
It's very common in pop/rock for the bass to move only by leaps to roots while the vocal melody moves in a more step-wise manner. By necessity those two lines are independent in terms of contour and relative motion. And, in pop/rock it would be very common for the bass and voice to be rhythmically independent.
Independent contours, independent rhythms: how is that not counterpoint?
The discussion on this post... Is there any name for two melodies that are being played at the same time? ...still sticks in my mind as making a muddle out of a simple idea: independence of contour and rhythm makes counterpoint.
add a comment |
I get the feeling the question is more along the lines of: is there counterpoint in homophonic music, or is a homophonic bass part a contrapuntal line?
I think the answer is yes to both.
It's very common in pop/rock for the bass to move only by leaps to roots while the vocal melody moves in a more step-wise manner. By necessity those two lines are independent in terms of contour and relative motion. And, in pop/rock it would be very common for the bass and voice to be rhythmically independent.
Independent contours, independent rhythms: how is that not counterpoint?
The discussion on this post... Is there any name for two melodies that are being played at the same time? ...still sticks in my mind as making a muddle out of a simple idea: independence of contour and rhythm makes counterpoint.
I get the feeling the question is more along the lines of: is there counterpoint in homophonic music, or is a homophonic bass part a contrapuntal line?
I think the answer is yes to both.
It's very common in pop/rock for the bass to move only by leaps to roots while the vocal melody moves in a more step-wise manner. By necessity those two lines are independent in terms of contour and relative motion. And, in pop/rock it would be very common for the bass and voice to be rhythmically independent.
Independent contours, independent rhythms: how is that not counterpoint?
The discussion on this post... Is there any name for two melodies that are being played at the same time? ...still sticks in my mind as making a muddle out of a simple idea: independence of contour and rhythm makes counterpoint.
edited Jun 4 at 16:43
answered Jun 4 at 16:26
Michael CurtisMichael Curtis
15k1051
15k1051
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Music: Practice & Theory Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmusic.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f85511%2fis-counterpoint-still-used-today%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
3
A shame that some feel the need to bash any post that in any way questions common practice harmony. +1.
– user45266
Jun 4 at 1:48
4
It's used a lot in popular music. Usually a line is sung by a lead vocalist then repeated by others with a varied melody. Here's some in the opening number of the musical Hamilton youtu.be/VhinPd5RRJw?t=166
– AJFaraday
Jun 4 at 8:18
I've heard this club/dance song incorporates counterpoint. youtu.be/WP47nuuOU_I (Reference: edmtunes.com/2014/05/look-mom-told-featuring-andrew-bayer)
– Wireblue
Jun 5 at 2:32