Source that a married woman seduced by a “messianic figure” is still permitted to her husbandReasons for divorcing a woman (sourcing a chiddush)Advantages of converts (in spiritual terms)Does every woman have a destined match?Why can the sister-in-law return to her husband according to R. Yosi? Isn't she forbidden to the husband and to the adulterer? (Y'vamos 10:4)

Counterfeit checks were created for my account. How does this type of fraud work?

What is the highest voltage from the power supply a Raspberry Pi 3 B can handle without getting damaged?

Primes and SemiPrimes in Binary

What are Elsa's reasons for selecting the Holy Grail on behalf of Donovan?

Understanding the reasoning of the woman who agreed with Shlomo to "cut the baby in half"

Why isn't my calculation that we should be able to see the sun well beyond the observable universe valid?

How would modern naval warfare have to have developed differently for battleships to still be relevant in the 21st century?

Dates on degrees don’t make sense – will people care?

Trainee keeps passing deadlines for independent learning

Is a single radon daughter atom in air a solid?

Is it illegal to withhold someone's passport and green card in California?

Encounter design and XP thresholds

How to maintain a closed environment for one person for a long period of time

Get list of shortcodes from content

Why are < or > required to use /dev/tcp

What happened to Steve's Shield in Iron Man 2?

What is "industrial ethernet"?

Similarity score: Can Sklearn SVR predict values greater than 1 and less than 0?

Prime sieve in Python

What determines the direction in which motor proteins go?

Boss wants someone else to lead a project based on the idea I presented to him

Cut the gold chain

RandomInteger with equal number of 1 and -1

Why does using different ArrayList constructors cause a different growth rate of the internal array?



Source that a married woman seduced by a “messianic figure” is still permitted to her husband


Reasons for divorcing a woman (sourcing a chiddush)Advantages of converts (in spiritual terms)Does every woman have a destined match?Why can the sister-in-law return to her husband according to R. Yosi? Isn't she forbidden to the husband and to the adulterer? (Y'vamos 10:4)






.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;








8















I've heard in the past that there is a responsum in regards to a married woman that was seduced by another man claiming to be the messiah, and the question arose about whether or not she was still permitted to her husband.



Does anyone know where this source of this tshuva comes from?










share|improve this question



















  • 1





    See the Malbim at the end of Bereishis. This is how he explains the pshat of אשר יבאו בני אלהים אל בנות האדם. Women would cheat on their husbands and then say "it was [insert idol name here] so it's ok."

    – Heshy
    Jun 4 at 9:33

















8















I've heard in the past that there is a responsum in regards to a married woman that was seduced by another man claiming to be the messiah, and the question arose about whether or not she was still permitted to her husband.



Does anyone know where this source of this tshuva comes from?










share|improve this question



















  • 1





    See the Malbim at the end of Bereishis. This is how he explains the pshat of אשר יבאו בני אלהים אל בנות האדם. Women would cheat on their husbands and then say "it was [insert idol name here] so it's ok."

    – Heshy
    Jun 4 at 9:33













8












8








8


2






I've heard in the past that there is a responsum in regards to a married woman that was seduced by another man claiming to be the messiah, and the question arose about whether or not she was still permitted to her husband.



Does anyone know where this source of this tshuva comes from?










share|improve this question
















I've heard in the past that there is a responsum in regards to a married woman that was seduced by another man claiming to be the messiah, and the question arose about whether or not she was still permitted to her husband.



Does anyone know where this source of this tshuva comes from?







sources-mekorot arayot responsa






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited Jun 4 at 13:23









Al Berko

7,7332631




7,7332631










asked Jun 4 at 8:10









Shoel U'MeishivShoel U'Meishiv

11.7k12765




11.7k12765







  • 1





    See the Malbim at the end of Bereishis. This is how he explains the pshat of אשר יבאו בני אלהים אל בנות האדם. Women would cheat on their husbands and then say "it was [insert idol name here] so it's ok."

    – Heshy
    Jun 4 at 9:33












  • 1





    See the Malbim at the end of Bereishis. This is how he explains the pshat of אשר יבאו בני אלהים אל בנות האדם. Women would cheat on their husbands and then say "it was [insert idol name here] so it's ok."

    – Heshy
    Jun 4 at 9:33







1




1





See the Malbim at the end of Bereishis. This is how he explains the pshat of אשר יבאו בני אלהים אל בנות האדם. Women would cheat on their husbands and then say "it was [insert idol name here] so it's ok."

– Heshy
Jun 4 at 9:33





See the Malbim at the end of Bereishis. This is how he explains the pshat of אשר יבאו בני אלהים אל בנות האדם. Women would cheat on their husbands and then say "it was [insert idol name here] so it's ok."

– Heshy
Jun 4 at 9:33










1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















13














It sounds like you might be looking for Binyan Tzion 154 (R. Yaakov Ettlinger). Although the case discussed is of a man claiming to be Elijah the Prophet, and seducing a woman by telling her that she will become the mother of the Messiah.



To quote sefaria's translation of the question:




Not long ago, an incident came before me that will cause the ears of all who hear it to ring. In one of the villages in my domain live two Jews who regularly take business trips extending several days, leaving their wives alone in the house with their sons and daughters and servants. One day, when one of the men went as was his way on a business trip, another man came from Poland, with torn clothes, and asked the wife for a place to lodge. The woman, who had always been exceedingly modest but whose piety was her folly, took pity on him and gave him a place to sleep and also food and drink. Yet that guest did not eat from her anything that had been alive, and drank nothing but water, and engaged in similar ascetic practices, afflicting himself with mortifications. All day he sat shut in his room with a book in hand, and also each night until midnight, upon which he would grieve over the destruction of God’s Temple. When he slept, he did not lie on a bed or bench, but rather on the ground, with rocks beneath his head. Each day he would immerse himself in the cold waters of the river twice, at the chilliest times. He behaved this way in the woman’s house from Sunday of Parashat Terumah until Shabbat of Parashat Tetzaveh.



But on Friday night, after the meal was over, the children and the house servants all left the table and went to sleep in the other room while that fraudulent man remained seated at the table, alone with the woman. He entered into conversation with her to the point that she asked “Who are you? Where do you come from? Where are you going?” He replied “I am an emissary of the Merciful One, and my name is Eliyahu the Prophet. I seek my brethren, to gather them from the four corners of the earth—but this can be told only to the discreet.” The woman, in her great foolishness believed him. She went to sleep on her bed in the adjacent room, while that menace still sat at his place. He studied a book until midnight, and after midnight he arose, tiptoed over to the bed where the woman was lying, woke her up from her sleep, and said to her: Behold I have travelled from one end of the earth to the other, and I have found no righteous woman to compare to you who is worth to produce the Messiah. The obstacle is your husband, who is not suitable for such. To that end, I have been sent from heaven to sleep with you, and in nine months you will bear a son who will be the Messiah, son of David. He will redeem Israel. This is your sign that I am Eliyahu; this coming Tuesday, after I take leave of you, if you open the door to the closet that stands here in your bedroom, you will find there a great treasure of 400 golden ducats—but only on condition that you do not open the closet before the prescribed time. Thus spoke the adulterer to her, until he seduced her. He defiled her twice, on Friday night and Saturday night, and on Sunday before dawn the adulterer fled from there. His whereabouts are unknown.




For an interesting analysis of R. Ettlinger's response see this article by R. Gidon Rothstein.






share|improve this answer




















  • 1





    You better quote the answer: "תשובה – חזרתי על כל צדדים וקשה מאוד למצוא תרופה ומזור למכת האולת שתהי' מותרת לבעלה כי מה שטוענת שוגגת היא וכונתה הי' לשם שמים אין זו טענה להתירה לפי משכ' המהרי"ק שרש קס"ח ונפסק ברמ"א אהע"ז (סי' קע"ח) שאם זינתה שסברה שמותר לזנות הוי כמזידה ואסורה לבעלה ישראל וכמו שהעיר גם מעלתו נ"י אמנם לקמן נדבר עוד מזה: "

    – Al Berko
    Jun 4 at 13:24







  • 3





    @AlBerko That's not his final conclusion... לפי אולתה היתה מצו' מן השמים על הבעילה עצמה ואין לך אונס גדול מזה ולא נתכוונה בהבעילה למעול בבעלה כי אם כמו שאמרה שסהדה במרומים שהי' כוונתה לש"ש לזה יש לדון שגם ע"פ מהרי"ק והאחרונים נקראה אונס גמור ומותרת לבעלה כנלענ"ד אכן אין לסמוך על הוראתי אם לא יסכימו על זה עוד שנים מבעלי הוראה ואז אצטרף עמהם להתיר אשה לבעלה ובפרט שכפי שנאמר בהשאלה אשה כשרה היתה מאז ויש להם בנים כנלענ"ד

    – Joel K
    Jun 4 at 13:28






  • 1





    +1 but very shver that he turns this into a bigger oness than Esther...

    – user6591
    Jun 4 at 15:58


















1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes








1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes









13














It sounds like you might be looking for Binyan Tzion 154 (R. Yaakov Ettlinger). Although the case discussed is of a man claiming to be Elijah the Prophet, and seducing a woman by telling her that she will become the mother of the Messiah.



To quote sefaria's translation of the question:




Not long ago, an incident came before me that will cause the ears of all who hear it to ring. In one of the villages in my domain live two Jews who regularly take business trips extending several days, leaving their wives alone in the house with their sons and daughters and servants. One day, when one of the men went as was his way on a business trip, another man came from Poland, with torn clothes, and asked the wife for a place to lodge. The woman, who had always been exceedingly modest but whose piety was her folly, took pity on him and gave him a place to sleep and also food and drink. Yet that guest did not eat from her anything that had been alive, and drank nothing but water, and engaged in similar ascetic practices, afflicting himself with mortifications. All day he sat shut in his room with a book in hand, and also each night until midnight, upon which he would grieve over the destruction of God’s Temple. When he slept, he did not lie on a bed or bench, but rather on the ground, with rocks beneath his head. Each day he would immerse himself in the cold waters of the river twice, at the chilliest times. He behaved this way in the woman’s house from Sunday of Parashat Terumah until Shabbat of Parashat Tetzaveh.



But on Friday night, after the meal was over, the children and the house servants all left the table and went to sleep in the other room while that fraudulent man remained seated at the table, alone with the woman. He entered into conversation with her to the point that she asked “Who are you? Where do you come from? Where are you going?” He replied “I am an emissary of the Merciful One, and my name is Eliyahu the Prophet. I seek my brethren, to gather them from the four corners of the earth—but this can be told only to the discreet.” The woman, in her great foolishness believed him. She went to sleep on her bed in the adjacent room, while that menace still sat at his place. He studied a book until midnight, and after midnight he arose, tiptoed over to the bed where the woman was lying, woke her up from her sleep, and said to her: Behold I have travelled from one end of the earth to the other, and I have found no righteous woman to compare to you who is worth to produce the Messiah. The obstacle is your husband, who is not suitable for such. To that end, I have been sent from heaven to sleep with you, and in nine months you will bear a son who will be the Messiah, son of David. He will redeem Israel. This is your sign that I am Eliyahu; this coming Tuesday, after I take leave of you, if you open the door to the closet that stands here in your bedroom, you will find there a great treasure of 400 golden ducats—but only on condition that you do not open the closet before the prescribed time. Thus spoke the adulterer to her, until he seduced her. He defiled her twice, on Friday night and Saturday night, and on Sunday before dawn the adulterer fled from there. His whereabouts are unknown.




For an interesting analysis of R. Ettlinger's response see this article by R. Gidon Rothstein.






share|improve this answer




















  • 1





    You better quote the answer: "תשובה – חזרתי על כל צדדים וקשה מאוד למצוא תרופה ומזור למכת האולת שתהי' מותרת לבעלה כי מה שטוענת שוגגת היא וכונתה הי' לשם שמים אין זו טענה להתירה לפי משכ' המהרי"ק שרש קס"ח ונפסק ברמ"א אהע"ז (סי' קע"ח) שאם זינתה שסברה שמותר לזנות הוי כמזידה ואסורה לבעלה ישראל וכמו שהעיר גם מעלתו נ"י אמנם לקמן נדבר עוד מזה: "

    – Al Berko
    Jun 4 at 13:24







  • 3





    @AlBerko That's not his final conclusion... לפי אולתה היתה מצו' מן השמים על הבעילה עצמה ואין לך אונס גדול מזה ולא נתכוונה בהבעילה למעול בבעלה כי אם כמו שאמרה שסהדה במרומים שהי' כוונתה לש"ש לזה יש לדון שגם ע"פ מהרי"ק והאחרונים נקראה אונס גמור ומותרת לבעלה כנלענ"ד אכן אין לסמוך על הוראתי אם לא יסכימו על זה עוד שנים מבעלי הוראה ואז אצטרף עמהם להתיר אשה לבעלה ובפרט שכפי שנאמר בהשאלה אשה כשרה היתה מאז ויש להם בנים כנלענ"ד

    – Joel K
    Jun 4 at 13:28






  • 1





    +1 but very shver that he turns this into a bigger oness than Esther...

    – user6591
    Jun 4 at 15:58















13














It sounds like you might be looking for Binyan Tzion 154 (R. Yaakov Ettlinger). Although the case discussed is of a man claiming to be Elijah the Prophet, and seducing a woman by telling her that she will become the mother of the Messiah.



To quote sefaria's translation of the question:




Not long ago, an incident came before me that will cause the ears of all who hear it to ring. In one of the villages in my domain live two Jews who regularly take business trips extending several days, leaving their wives alone in the house with their sons and daughters and servants. One day, when one of the men went as was his way on a business trip, another man came from Poland, with torn clothes, and asked the wife for a place to lodge. The woman, who had always been exceedingly modest but whose piety was her folly, took pity on him and gave him a place to sleep and also food and drink. Yet that guest did not eat from her anything that had been alive, and drank nothing but water, and engaged in similar ascetic practices, afflicting himself with mortifications. All day he sat shut in his room with a book in hand, and also each night until midnight, upon which he would grieve over the destruction of God’s Temple. When he slept, he did not lie on a bed or bench, but rather on the ground, with rocks beneath his head. Each day he would immerse himself in the cold waters of the river twice, at the chilliest times. He behaved this way in the woman’s house from Sunday of Parashat Terumah until Shabbat of Parashat Tetzaveh.



But on Friday night, after the meal was over, the children and the house servants all left the table and went to sleep in the other room while that fraudulent man remained seated at the table, alone with the woman. He entered into conversation with her to the point that she asked “Who are you? Where do you come from? Where are you going?” He replied “I am an emissary of the Merciful One, and my name is Eliyahu the Prophet. I seek my brethren, to gather them from the four corners of the earth—but this can be told only to the discreet.” The woman, in her great foolishness believed him. She went to sleep on her bed in the adjacent room, while that menace still sat at his place. He studied a book until midnight, and after midnight he arose, tiptoed over to the bed where the woman was lying, woke her up from her sleep, and said to her: Behold I have travelled from one end of the earth to the other, and I have found no righteous woman to compare to you who is worth to produce the Messiah. The obstacle is your husband, who is not suitable for such. To that end, I have been sent from heaven to sleep with you, and in nine months you will bear a son who will be the Messiah, son of David. He will redeem Israel. This is your sign that I am Eliyahu; this coming Tuesday, after I take leave of you, if you open the door to the closet that stands here in your bedroom, you will find there a great treasure of 400 golden ducats—but only on condition that you do not open the closet before the prescribed time. Thus spoke the adulterer to her, until he seduced her. He defiled her twice, on Friday night and Saturday night, and on Sunday before dawn the adulterer fled from there. His whereabouts are unknown.




For an interesting analysis of R. Ettlinger's response see this article by R. Gidon Rothstein.






share|improve this answer




















  • 1





    You better quote the answer: "תשובה – חזרתי על כל צדדים וקשה מאוד למצוא תרופה ומזור למכת האולת שתהי' מותרת לבעלה כי מה שטוענת שוגגת היא וכונתה הי' לשם שמים אין זו טענה להתירה לפי משכ' המהרי"ק שרש קס"ח ונפסק ברמ"א אהע"ז (סי' קע"ח) שאם זינתה שסברה שמותר לזנות הוי כמזידה ואסורה לבעלה ישראל וכמו שהעיר גם מעלתו נ"י אמנם לקמן נדבר עוד מזה: "

    – Al Berko
    Jun 4 at 13:24







  • 3





    @AlBerko That's not his final conclusion... לפי אולתה היתה מצו' מן השמים על הבעילה עצמה ואין לך אונס גדול מזה ולא נתכוונה בהבעילה למעול בבעלה כי אם כמו שאמרה שסהדה במרומים שהי' כוונתה לש"ש לזה יש לדון שגם ע"פ מהרי"ק והאחרונים נקראה אונס גמור ומותרת לבעלה כנלענ"ד אכן אין לסמוך על הוראתי אם לא יסכימו על זה עוד שנים מבעלי הוראה ואז אצטרף עמהם להתיר אשה לבעלה ובפרט שכפי שנאמר בהשאלה אשה כשרה היתה מאז ויש להם בנים כנלענ"ד

    – Joel K
    Jun 4 at 13:28






  • 1





    +1 but very shver that he turns this into a bigger oness than Esther...

    – user6591
    Jun 4 at 15:58













13












13








13







It sounds like you might be looking for Binyan Tzion 154 (R. Yaakov Ettlinger). Although the case discussed is of a man claiming to be Elijah the Prophet, and seducing a woman by telling her that she will become the mother of the Messiah.



To quote sefaria's translation of the question:




Not long ago, an incident came before me that will cause the ears of all who hear it to ring. In one of the villages in my domain live two Jews who regularly take business trips extending several days, leaving their wives alone in the house with their sons and daughters and servants. One day, when one of the men went as was his way on a business trip, another man came from Poland, with torn clothes, and asked the wife for a place to lodge. The woman, who had always been exceedingly modest but whose piety was her folly, took pity on him and gave him a place to sleep and also food and drink. Yet that guest did not eat from her anything that had been alive, and drank nothing but water, and engaged in similar ascetic practices, afflicting himself with mortifications. All day he sat shut in his room with a book in hand, and also each night until midnight, upon which he would grieve over the destruction of God’s Temple. When he slept, he did not lie on a bed or bench, but rather on the ground, with rocks beneath his head. Each day he would immerse himself in the cold waters of the river twice, at the chilliest times. He behaved this way in the woman’s house from Sunday of Parashat Terumah until Shabbat of Parashat Tetzaveh.



But on Friday night, after the meal was over, the children and the house servants all left the table and went to sleep in the other room while that fraudulent man remained seated at the table, alone with the woman. He entered into conversation with her to the point that she asked “Who are you? Where do you come from? Where are you going?” He replied “I am an emissary of the Merciful One, and my name is Eliyahu the Prophet. I seek my brethren, to gather them from the four corners of the earth—but this can be told only to the discreet.” The woman, in her great foolishness believed him. She went to sleep on her bed in the adjacent room, while that menace still sat at his place. He studied a book until midnight, and after midnight he arose, tiptoed over to the bed where the woman was lying, woke her up from her sleep, and said to her: Behold I have travelled from one end of the earth to the other, and I have found no righteous woman to compare to you who is worth to produce the Messiah. The obstacle is your husband, who is not suitable for such. To that end, I have been sent from heaven to sleep with you, and in nine months you will bear a son who will be the Messiah, son of David. He will redeem Israel. This is your sign that I am Eliyahu; this coming Tuesday, after I take leave of you, if you open the door to the closet that stands here in your bedroom, you will find there a great treasure of 400 golden ducats—but only on condition that you do not open the closet before the prescribed time. Thus spoke the adulterer to her, until he seduced her. He defiled her twice, on Friday night and Saturday night, and on Sunday before dawn the adulterer fled from there. His whereabouts are unknown.




For an interesting analysis of R. Ettlinger's response see this article by R. Gidon Rothstein.






share|improve this answer















It sounds like you might be looking for Binyan Tzion 154 (R. Yaakov Ettlinger). Although the case discussed is of a man claiming to be Elijah the Prophet, and seducing a woman by telling her that she will become the mother of the Messiah.



To quote sefaria's translation of the question:




Not long ago, an incident came before me that will cause the ears of all who hear it to ring. In one of the villages in my domain live two Jews who regularly take business trips extending several days, leaving their wives alone in the house with their sons and daughters and servants. One day, when one of the men went as was his way on a business trip, another man came from Poland, with torn clothes, and asked the wife for a place to lodge. The woman, who had always been exceedingly modest but whose piety was her folly, took pity on him and gave him a place to sleep and also food and drink. Yet that guest did not eat from her anything that had been alive, and drank nothing but water, and engaged in similar ascetic practices, afflicting himself with mortifications. All day he sat shut in his room with a book in hand, and also each night until midnight, upon which he would grieve over the destruction of God’s Temple. When he slept, he did not lie on a bed or bench, but rather on the ground, with rocks beneath his head. Each day he would immerse himself in the cold waters of the river twice, at the chilliest times. He behaved this way in the woman’s house from Sunday of Parashat Terumah until Shabbat of Parashat Tetzaveh.



But on Friday night, after the meal was over, the children and the house servants all left the table and went to sleep in the other room while that fraudulent man remained seated at the table, alone with the woman. He entered into conversation with her to the point that she asked “Who are you? Where do you come from? Where are you going?” He replied “I am an emissary of the Merciful One, and my name is Eliyahu the Prophet. I seek my brethren, to gather them from the four corners of the earth—but this can be told only to the discreet.” The woman, in her great foolishness believed him. She went to sleep on her bed in the adjacent room, while that menace still sat at his place. He studied a book until midnight, and after midnight he arose, tiptoed over to the bed where the woman was lying, woke her up from her sleep, and said to her: Behold I have travelled from one end of the earth to the other, and I have found no righteous woman to compare to you who is worth to produce the Messiah. The obstacle is your husband, who is not suitable for such. To that end, I have been sent from heaven to sleep with you, and in nine months you will bear a son who will be the Messiah, son of David. He will redeem Israel. This is your sign that I am Eliyahu; this coming Tuesday, after I take leave of you, if you open the door to the closet that stands here in your bedroom, you will find there a great treasure of 400 golden ducats—but only on condition that you do not open the closet before the prescribed time. Thus spoke the adulterer to her, until he seduced her. He defiled her twice, on Friday night and Saturday night, and on Sunday before dawn the adulterer fled from there. His whereabouts are unknown.




For an interesting analysis of R. Ettlinger's response see this article by R. Gidon Rothstein.







share|improve this answer














share|improve this answer



share|improve this answer








edited Jun 4 at 9:55

























answered Jun 4 at 9:53









Joel KJoel K

17.1k230104




17.1k230104







  • 1





    You better quote the answer: "תשובה – חזרתי על כל צדדים וקשה מאוד למצוא תרופה ומזור למכת האולת שתהי' מותרת לבעלה כי מה שטוענת שוגגת היא וכונתה הי' לשם שמים אין זו טענה להתירה לפי משכ' המהרי"ק שרש קס"ח ונפסק ברמ"א אהע"ז (סי' קע"ח) שאם זינתה שסברה שמותר לזנות הוי כמזידה ואסורה לבעלה ישראל וכמו שהעיר גם מעלתו נ"י אמנם לקמן נדבר עוד מזה: "

    – Al Berko
    Jun 4 at 13:24







  • 3





    @AlBerko That's not his final conclusion... לפי אולתה היתה מצו' מן השמים על הבעילה עצמה ואין לך אונס גדול מזה ולא נתכוונה בהבעילה למעול בבעלה כי אם כמו שאמרה שסהדה במרומים שהי' כוונתה לש"ש לזה יש לדון שגם ע"פ מהרי"ק והאחרונים נקראה אונס גמור ומותרת לבעלה כנלענ"ד אכן אין לסמוך על הוראתי אם לא יסכימו על זה עוד שנים מבעלי הוראה ואז אצטרף עמהם להתיר אשה לבעלה ובפרט שכפי שנאמר בהשאלה אשה כשרה היתה מאז ויש להם בנים כנלענ"ד

    – Joel K
    Jun 4 at 13:28






  • 1





    +1 but very shver that he turns this into a bigger oness than Esther...

    – user6591
    Jun 4 at 15:58












  • 1





    You better quote the answer: "תשובה – חזרתי על כל צדדים וקשה מאוד למצוא תרופה ומזור למכת האולת שתהי' מותרת לבעלה כי מה שטוענת שוגגת היא וכונתה הי' לשם שמים אין זו טענה להתירה לפי משכ' המהרי"ק שרש קס"ח ונפסק ברמ"א אהע"ז (סי' קע"ח) שאם זינתה שסברה שמותר לזנות הוי כמזידה ואסורה לבעלה ישראל וכמו שהעיר גם מעלתו נ"י אמנם לקמן נדבר עוד מזה: "

    – Al Berko
    Jun 4 at 13:24







  • 3





    @AlBerko That's not his final conclusion... לפי אולתה היתה מצו' מן השמים על הבעילה עצמה ואין לך אונס גדול מזה ולא נתכוונה בהבעילה למעול בבעלה כי אם כמו שאמרה שסהדה במרומים שהי' כוונתה לש"ש לזה יש לדון שגם ע"פ מהרי"ק והאחרונים נקראה אונס גמור ומותרת לבעלה כנלענ"ד אכן אין לסמוך על הוראתי אם לא יסכימו על זה עוד שנים מבעלי הוראה ואז אצטרף עמהם להתיר אשה לבעלה ובפרט שכפי שנאמר בהשאלה אשה כשרה היתה מאז ויש להם בנים כנלענ"ד

    – Joel K
    Jun 4 at 13:28






  • 1





    +1 but very shver that he turns this into a bigger oness than Esther...

    – user6591
    Jun 4 at 15:58







1




1





You better quote the answer: "תשובה – חזרתי על כל צדדים וקשה מאוד למצוא תרופה ומזור למכת האולת שתהי' מותרת לבעלה כי מה שטוענת שוגגת היא וכונתה הי' לשם שמים אין זו טענה להתירה לפי משכ' המהרי"ק שרש קס"ח ונפסק ברמ"א אהע"ז (סי' קע"ח) שאם זינתה שסברה שמותר לזנות הוי כמזידה ואסורה לבעלה ישראל וכמו שהעיר גם מעלתו נ"י אמנם לקמן נדבר עוד מזה: "

– Al Berko
Jun 4 at 13:24






You better quote the answer: "תשובה – חזרתי על כל צדדים וקשה מאוד למצוא תרופה ומזור למכת האולת שתהי' מותרת לבעלה כי מה שטוענת שוגגת היא וכונתה הי' לשם שמים אין זו טענה להתירה לפי משכ' המהרי"ק שרש קס"ח ונפסק ברמ"א אהע"ז (סי' קע"ח) שאם זינתה שסברה שמותר לזנות הוי כמזידה ואסורה לבעלה ישראל וכמו שהעיר גם מעלתו נ"י אמנם לקמן נדבר עוד מזה: "

– Al Berko
Jun 4 at 13:24





3




3





@AlBerko That's not his final conclusion... לפי אולתה היתה מצו' מן השמים על הבעילה עצמה ואין לך אונס גדול מזה ולא נתכוונה בהבעילה למעול בבעלה כי אם כמו שאמרה שסהדה במרומים שהי' כוונתה לש"ש לזה יש לדון שגם ע"פ מהרי"ק והאחרונים נקראה אונס גמור ומותרת לבעלה כנלענ"ד אכן אין לסמוך על הוראתי אם לא יסכימו על זה עוד שנים מבעלי הוראה ואז אצטרף עמהם להתיר אשה לבעלה ובפרט שכפי שנאמר בהשאלה אשה כשרה היתה מאז ויש להם בנים כנלענ"ד

– Joel K
Jun 4 at 13:28





@AlBerko That's not his final conclusion... לפי אולתה היתה מצו' מן השמים על הבעילה עצמה ואין לך אונס גדול מזה ולא נתכוונה בהבעילה למעול בבעלה כי אם כמו שאמרה שסהדה במרומים שהי' כוונתה לש"ש לזה יש לדון שגם ע"פ מהרי"ק והאחרונים נקראה אונס גמור ומותרת לבעלה כנלענ"ד אכן אין לסמוך על הוראתי אם לא יסכימו על זה עוד שנים מבעלי הוראה ואז אצטרף עמהם להתיר אשה לבעלה ובפרט שכפי שנאמר בהשאלה אשה כשרה היתה מאז ויש להם בנים כנלענ"ד

– Joel K
Jun 4 at 13:28




1




1





+1 but very shver that he turns this into a bigger oness than Esther...

– user6591
Jun 4 at 15:58





+1 but very shver that he turns this into a bigger oness than Esther...

– user6591
Jun 4 at 15:58



Popular posts from this blog

Wikipedia:Vital articles Мазмуну Biography - Өмүр баян Philosophy and psychology - Философия жана психология Religion - Дин Social sciences - Коомдук илимдер Language and literature - Тил жана адабият Science - Илим Technology - Технология Arts and recreation - Искусство жана эс алуу History and geography - Тарых жана география Навигация менюсу

Bruxelas-Capital Índice Historia | Composición | Situación lingüística | Clima | Cidades irmandadas | Notas | Véxase tamén | Menú de navegacióneO uso das linguas en Bruxelas e a situación do neerlandés"Rexión de Bruxelas Capital"o orixinalSitio da rexiónPáxina de Bruselas no sitio da Oficina de Promoción Turística de Valonia e BruxelasMapa Interactivo da Rexión de Bruxelas-CapitaleeWorldCat332144929079854441105155190212ID28008674080552-90000 0001 0666 3698n94104302ID540940339365017018237

What should I write in an apology letter, since I have decided not to join a company after accepting an offer letterShould I keep looking after accepting a job offer?What should I do when I've been verbally told I would get an offer letter, but still haven't gotten one after 4 weeks?Do I accept an offer from a company that I am not likely to join?New job hasn't confirmed starting date and I want to give current employer as much notice as possibleHow should I address my manager in my resignation letter?HR delayed background verification, now jobless as resignedNo email communication after accepting a formal written offer. How should I phrase the call?What should I do if after receiving a verbal offer letter I am informed that my written job offer is put on hold due to some internal issues?Should I inform the current employer that I am about to resign within 1-2 weeks since I have signed the offer letter and waiting for visa?What company will do, if I send their offer letter to another company