Otdfbt

Multi tool use

Secure offsite backup, even in the case of hacker root access

Movie where a boy is transported into the future by an alien spaceship

Credit card offering 0.5 miles for every cent rounded up. Too good to be true?

Pros and cons of writing a book review?

How certain is a caster of when their spell will end?

What is the right way to float a home lab?

Why is the relationship between frequency and pitch exponential?

Is it a problem that pull requests are approved without any comments

Pronoun introduced before its antecedent

Is the decompression of compressed and encrypted data without decryption also theoretically impossible?

Did thousands of women die every year due to illegal abortions before Roe v. Wade?

Company is asking me to work from overseas, but wants me to take a paycut

Is there any word or phrase for negative bearing?

X-shaped crossword

Can a magnetic field of an object be stronger than its gravity?

Working in the USA for living expenses only; allowed on VWP?

When writing an error prompt, should we end the sentence with a exclamation mark or a dot?

Word for a small burst of laughter that can't be held back

Shrink exponential fraction argument

Applicants clearly not having the skills they advertise

You've spoiled/damaged the card

Why don't B747s start takeoffs with full throttle?

How to make thick Asian sauces?

Incremental Ranges!

Permissibility Of Unneeded Hysterectomy

Is autocannibalism halachically prohibited?Halachic permissibility of a vasectomyMust a woman cover her hair during childbirth?Permissibility of removing wisdom teethHorse back riding for womenClarifying the prohibition of Mishkav ZacharAre there any sources that prohibit childhood vaccinations?Kohen marrying a giyoressWhy does medical marijuana need a kosher supervision?Are there any halachic issues involved with using jscreen?

2

Is it halachically ok for a woman have a hysterectomy if there is no medical need? If not, is it permissible as a form of contraceptive?

halacha women medicine

share|improve this question

edited May 19 at 1:20

Double AA♦

80.2k6200439

asked May 18 at 13:26

GabrielGabriel

434

add a comment | 

2

Is it halachically ok for a woman have a hysterectomy if there is no medical need? If not, is it permissible as a form of contraceptive?

halacha women medicine

share|improve this question

edited May 19 at 1:20

Double AA♦

80.2k6200439

asked May 18 at 13:26

GabrielGabriel

434

add a comment | 

Is it halachically ok for a woman have a hysterectomy if there is no medical need? If not, is it permissible as a form of contraceptive?

halacha women medicine

share|improve this question

edited May 19 at 1:20

Double AA♦

80.2k6200439

asked May 18 at 13:26

GabrielGabriel

434

share|improve this question

edited May 19 at 1:20

Double AA♦

80.2k6200439

asked May 18 at 13:26

GabrielGabriel

434

share|improve this question

edited May 19 at 1:20

Double AA♦

80.2k6200439

asked May 18 at 13:26

GabrielGabriel

434

edited May 19 at 1:20

Double AA♦

80.2k6200439

edited May 19 at 1:20

Double AA♦

80.2k6200439

asked May 18 at 13:26

GabrielGabriel

434

asked May 18 at 13:26

GabrielGabriel

434

1 Answer
1

active

oldest

votes

4

That's a dispute between Tane Kamah and R' Yehuda regarding the prohibition of castrating in Tosefta Makos 4 4:

המסרס את האדם ואת הבהמה ואת החיה ואת העוף,

בין גדולים בין קטנים,
בין זכרים ובין נקבות

– הרי זה חייב (מלקות).

רבי יהודה אומר: מסרס את הזכרים – חייב,

ואת הנקבות – פטור (מהתורה, אבל אסור מדרבנן).

(Tane Kame says removing woman's reproductory system transgresses the Negative commandment Deorayso, and R' Yehudah says, that it is not (Deorayso as women are not commanded on reproduction, but still forbidden Derabanan)

Most of the following Poskim Follow R"Y's approach, making it forbidden Derabanan.

share|improve this answer

edited May 19 at 8:23

Kazi bácsi

2,87611030

answered May 18 at 19:35

Al BerkoAl Berko

7,5012631

add a comment | 

4

That's a dispute between Tane Kamah and R' Yehuda regarding the prohibition of castrating in Tosefta Makos 4 4:

המסרס את האדם ואת הבהמה ואת החיה ואת העוף,

בין גדולים בין קטנים,
בין זכרים ובין נקבות

– הרי זה חייב (מלקות).

רבי יהודה אומר: מסרס את הזכרים – חייב,

ואת הנקבות – פטור (מהתורה, אבל אסור מדרבנן).

(Tane Kame says removing woman's reproductory system transgresses the Negative commandment Deorayso, and R' Yehudah says, that it is not (Deorayso as women are not commanded on reproduction, but still forbidden Derabanan)

Most of the following Poskim Follow R"Y's approach, making it forbidden Derabanan.

share|improve this answer

edited May 19 at 8:23

Kazi bácsi

2,87611030

answered May 18 at 19:35

Al BerkoAl Berko

7,5012631

add a comment | 

4

That's a dispute between Tane Kamah and R' Yehuda regarding the prohibition of castrating in Tosefta Makos 4 4:

המסרס את האדם ואת הבהמה ואת החיה ואת העוף,

בין גדולים בין קטנים,
בין זכרים ובין נקבות

– הרי זה חייב (מלקות).

רבי יהודה אומר: מסרס את הזכרים – חייב,

ואת הנקבות – פטור (מהתורה, אבל אסור מדרבנן).

(Tane Kame says removing woman's reproductory system transgresses the Negative commandment Deorayso, and R' Yehudah says, that it is not (Deorayso as women are not commanded on reproduction, but still forbidden Derabanan)

Most of the following Poskim Follow R"Y's approach, making it forbidden Derabanan.

share|improve this answer

edited May 19 at 8:23

Kazi bácsi

2,87611030

answered May 18 at 19:35

Al BerkoAl Berko

7,5012631

add a comment | 

That's a dispute between Tane Kamah and R' Yehuda regarding the prohibition of castrating in Tosefta Makos 4 4:

המסרס את האדם ואת הבהמה ואת החיה ואת העוף,

בין גדולים בין קטנים,
בין זכרים ובין נקבות

– הרי זה חייב (מלקות).

רבי יהודה אומר: מסרס את הזכרים – חייב,

ואת הנקבות – פטור (מהתורה, אבל אסור מדרבנן).

(Tane Kame says removing woman's reproductory system transgresses the Negative commandment Deorayso, and R' Yehudah says, that it is not (Deorayso as women are not commanded on reproduction, but still forbidden Derabanan)

Most of the following Poskim Follow R"Y's approach, making it forbidden Derabanan.

share|improve this answer

edited May 19 at 8:23

Kazi bácsi

2,87611030

answered May 18 at 19:35

Al BerkoAl Berko

7,5012631

share|improve this answer

edited May 19 at 8:23

Kazi bácsi

2,87611030

answered May 18 at 19:35

Al BerkoAl Berko

7,5012631

edited May 19 at 8:23

Kazi bácsi

2,87611030

edited May 19 at 8:23

Kazi bácsi

2,87611030

answered May 18 at 19:35

Al BerkoAl Berko

7,5012631

answered May 18 at 19:35

Al BerkoAl Berko

7,5012631