Why did Rep. Omar conclude her criticism of US troops with the phrase “NotTodaySatan”? [closed]How did House Resolution 367 pass on the same day as introduced without a 2/3 majority?Why did Senator Rand Paul speak for ten hours on 20th May 2015 and why did he stop before midnight?Why did Obama commute Chelsea Manning's sentence?What pressure was President Clinton under when he refused to call the Rwandan Genocide by its name?Did Juanita Broaddrick testify under oath against Bill Clinton?Why wasn't Elena Kagan's lack of *judicial* experience an issue?Did Brett Kavanaugh perjure himself with regard to a New Yorker article?Why is Elizabeth Warren's Native American ancestry a political issue?When did Elizabeth Warren first refer to her Native American ancestry?Congress's power to Declare War vs Authorization to Use Military Forces (AUMF)
Does "Captain Marvel" contain spoilers for "Avengers: Infinity War"?
Why would a military not separate its forces into different branches?
Is “snitty” a popular American English term? What is its origin?
Are sleeping system R-ratings additive?
How should I tell my manager I'm not paying for an optional after work event I'm not going to?
Any examples of liquids volatile at room temp but non-flammable?
SOQL query WHERE filter by specific months
Can I use a Cat5e cable with an RJ45 and Cat6 port?
When does tabularx decide to break the cell entry instead of reducing the columns separation?
Will 700 more planes a day fly because of the Heathrow expansion?
Is there precedent or are there procedures for a US president refusing to concede to an electoral defeat?
Is any special diet a treatment of autism?
Why symmetry transformations have to commute with Hamiltonian?
Would you use "llamarse" for an animal's name?
Indentation Tex
Why is my arithmetic with a long long int behaving this way?
Prove that a definite integral is an infinite sum
What was Bran's plan to kill the Night King?
Would a small hole in a Faraday cage drastically reduce its effectiveness at blocking interference?
Why didn't this character get a funeral at the end of Avengers: Endgame?
Are the Night's Watch still required?
Why does sound not move through a wall?
My first c++ game (snake console game)
Correct way of drawing empty, half-filled and fully filled circles?
Why did Rep. Omar conclude her criticism of US troops with the phrase “NotTodaySatan”? [closed]
How did House Resolution 367 pass on the same day as introduced without a 2/3 majority?Why did Senator Rand Paul speak for ten hours on 20th May 2015 and why did he stop before midnight?Why did Obama commute Chelsea Manning's sentence?What pressure was President Clinton under when he refused to call the Rwandan Genocide by its name?Did Juanita Broaddrick testify under oath against Bill Clinton?Why wasn't Elena Kagan's lack of *judicial* experience an issue?Did Brett Kavanaugh perjure himself with regard to a New Yorker article?Why is Elizabeth Warren's Native American ancestry a political issue?When did Elizabeth Warren first refer to her Native American ancestry?Congress's power to Declare War vs Authorization to Use Military Forces (AUMF)
Putting aside whether or not Omar was truthful when she tweeted:
...the thousands of Somalis killed by the American forces that day
(in reference to the October 1993 Battle of Mogadishu)
Why did she conclude her criticism of US troops with the hashtag "#NotTodaySatan"?
united-states somalia
edited Apr 25 at 20:03
JJJ
8,03732966
asked Apr 25 at 19:56
DavePhDDavePhD
1,441515
closed as off-topic by Karlomanio, JJJ, Azor Ahai, bytebuster, theresawalrus Apr 26 at 14:22
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Questions asking for the internal motivations of people, how specific individuals would behave in hypothetical situations or predictions for future events are off-topic, because answers would be based on speculation and their correctness could not be verified with sources available to the public." – JJJ, Azor Ahai, bytebuster, theresawalrus
|
show 1 more comment
Putting aside whether or not Omar was truthful when she tweeted:
...the thousands of Somalis killed by the American forces that day
(in reference to the October 1993 Battle of Mogadishu)
Why did she conclude her criticism of US troops with the hashtag "#NotTodaySatan"?
united-states somalia
edited Apr 25 at 20:03
JJJ
8,03732966
asked Apr 25 at 19:56
DavePhDDavePhD
1,441515
closed as off-topic by Karlomanio, JJJ, Azor Ahai, bytebuster, theresawalrus Apr 26 at 14:22
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Questions asking for the internal motivations of people, how specific individuals would behave in hypothetical situations or predictions for future events are off-topic, because answers would be based on speculation and their correctness could not be verified with sources available to the public." – JJJ, Azor Ahai, bytebuster, theresawalrus
It looks like a contemporaneous meme given that the tweet was from 2017. There are multiple reads of what she could be saying though.
– hszmv
Apr 25 at 21:03
5
Where does the "her criticism of US troops" in the title come from? The tweet you link is concerned with correcting an incredibly racist statement. I don't see how it makes any special effort to criticize US troops. It does state that US troops kill people - but as an answer to somebody implying they didn't, you can hardly consider that "criticism".
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 11:34
@R.Schmitz I think it's clear that she is criticizing the number of Somalis killed. Whether she blames Clinton, or the troops actually in Somalia, or the chain of command somewhere in between, I don't know.
– DavePhD
Apr 26 at 11:43
3
@DavePhD With all due respect, no it's not. Just saying "US troops kill so-and-so many people" is not criticism, it's a statistic. Now, "killing people" is not a good thing, but if somebody says "they killed 12 people" and I say "no, it was 14", then that's not criticism. We can consider the perspective that this one tweet is part of a bigger narrative... but then she didn't "conclude" that with NotTodaySatan.
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 11:52
1
@DavePhD "Yes, it's part of a bigger narrative." which isn't "concluded" with #NotTodaySatan - that's my point for this perspective.
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 12:21
|
show 1 more comment
Putting aside whether or not Omar was truthful when she tweeted:
...the thousands of Somalis killed by the American forces that day
(in reference to the October 1993 Battle of Mogadishu)
Why did she conclude her criticism of US troops with the hashtag "#NotTodaySatan"?
united-states somalia
edited Apr 25 at 20:03
JJJ
8,03732966
asked Apr 25 at 19:56
DavePhDDavePhD
1,441515
Putting aside whether or not Omar was truthful when she tweeted:
...the thousands of Somalis killed by the American forces that day
(in reference to the October 1993 Battle of Mogadishu)
Why did she conclude her criticism of US troops with the hashtag "#NotTodaySatan"?
united-states somalia
united-states somalia
edited Apr 25 at 20:03
JJJ
8,03732966
asked Apr 25 at 19:56
DavePhDDavePhD
1,441515
edited Apr 25 at 20:03
JJJ
8,03732966
asked Apr 25 at 19:56
DavePhDDavePhD
1,441515
edited Apr 25 at 20:03
JJJ
8,03732966
edited Apr 25 at 20:03
JJJ
8,03732966
edited Apr 25 at 20:03
JJJ
8,03732966
8,03732966
asked Apr 25 at 19:56
DavePhDDavePhD
1,441515
asked Apr 25 at 19:56
DavePhDDavePhD
1,441515
asked Apr 25 at 19:56
DavePhDDavePhD
1,441515
1,441515
closed as off-topic by Karlomanio, JJJ, Azor Ahai, bytebuster, theresawalrus Apr 26 at 14:22
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Questions asking for the internal motivations of people, how specific individuals would behave in hypothetical situations or predictions for future events are off-topic, because answers would be based on speculation and their correctness could not be verified with sources available to the public." – JJJ, Azor Ahai, bytebuster, theresawalrus
closed as off-topic by Karlomanio, JJJ, Azor Ahai, bytebuster, theresawalrus Apr 26 at 14:22
This question appears to be off-topic. The users who voted to close gave this specific reason:
- "Questions asking for the internal motivations of people, how specific individuals would behave in hypothetical situations or predictions for future events are off-topic, because answers would be based on speculation and their correctness could not be verified with sources available to the public." – JJJ, Azor Ahai, bytebuster, theresawalrus
It looks like a contemporaneous meme given that the tweet was from 2017. There are multiple reads of what she could be saying though.
– hszmv
Apr 25 at 21:03
5
Where does the "her criticism of US troops" in the title come from? The tweet you link is concerned with correcting an incredibly racist statement. I don't see how it makes any special effort to criticize US troops. It does state that US troops kill people - but as an answer to somebody implying they didn't, you can hardly consider that "criticism".
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 11:34
@R.Schmitz I think it's clear that she is criticizing the number of Somalis killed. Whether she blames Clinton, or the troops actually in Somalia, or the chain of command somewhere in between, I don't know.
– DavePhD
Apr 26 at 11:43
3
@DavePhD With all due respect, no it's not. Just saying "US troops kill so-and-so many people" is not criticism, it's a statistic. Now, "killing people" is not a good thing, but if somebody says "they killed 12 people" and I say "no, it was 14", then that's not criticism. We can consider the perspective that this one tweet is part of a bigger narrative... but then she didn't "conclude" that with NotTodaySatan.
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 11:52
1
@DavePhD "Yes, it's part of a bigger narrative." which isn't "concluded" with #NotTodaySatan - that's my point for this perspective.
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 12:21
|
show 1 more comment
It looks like a contemporaneous meme given that the tweet was from 2017. There are multiple reads of what she could be saying though.
– hszmv
Apr 25 at 21:03
5
Where does the "her criticism of US troops" in the title come from? The tweet you link is concerned with correcting an incredibly racist statement. I don't see how it makes any special effort to criticize US troops. It does state that US troops kill people - but as an answer to somebody implying they didn't, you can hardly consider that "criticism".
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 11:34
@R.Schmitz I think it's clear that she is criticizing the number of Somalis killed. Whether she blames Clinton, or the troops actually in Somalia, or the chain of command somewhere in between, I don't know.
– DavePhD
Apr 26 at 11:43
3
@DavePhD With all due respect, no it's not. Just saying "US troops kill so-and-so many people" is not criticism, it's a statistic. Now, "killing people" is not a good thing, but if somebody says "they killed 12 people" and I say "no, it was 14", then that's not criticism. We can consider the perspective that this one tweet is part of a bigger narrative... but then she didn't "conclude" that with NotTodaySatan.
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 11:52
1
@DavePhD "Yes, it's part of a bigger narrative." which isn't "concluded" with #NotTodaySatan - that's my point for this perspective.
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 12:21
It looks like a contemporaneous meme given that the tweet was from 2017. There are multiple reads of what she could be saying though.
– hszmv
Apr 25 at 21:03
It looks like a contemporaneous meme given that the tweet was from 2017. There are multiple reads of what she could be saying though.
– hszmv
Apr 25 at 21:03
5
5
Where does the "her criticism of US troops" in the title come from? The tweet you link is concerned with correcting an incredibly racist statement. I don't see how it makes any special effort to criticize US troops. It does state that US troops kill people - but as an answer to somebody implying they didn't, you can hardly consider that "criticism".
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 11:34
Where does the "her criticism of US troops" in the title come from? The tweet you link is concerned with correcting an incredibly racist statement. I don't see how it makes any special effort to criticize US troops. It does state that US troops kill people - but as an answer to somebody implying they didn't, you can hardly consider that "criticism".
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 11:34
@R.Schmitz I think it's clear that she is criticizing the number of Somalis killed. Whether she blames Clinton, or the troops actually in Somalia, or the chain of command somewhere in between, I don't know.
– DavePhD
Apr 26 at 11:43
@R.Schmitz I think it's clear that she is criticizing the number of Somalis killed. Whether she blames Clinton, or the troops actually in Somalia, or the chain of command somewhere in between, I don't know.
– DavePhD
Apr 26 at 11:43
3
3
@DavePhD With all due respect, no it's not. Just saying "US troops kill so-and-so many people" is not criticism, it's a statistic. Now, "killing people" is not a good thing, but if somebody says "they killed 12 people" and I say "no, it was 14", then that's not criticism. We can consider the perspective that this one tweet is part of a bigger narrative... but then she didn't "conclude" that with NotTodaySatan.
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 11:52
@DavePhD With all due respect, no it's not. Just saying "US troops kill so-and-so many people" is not criticism, it's a statistic. Now, "killing people" is not a good thing, but if somebody says "they killed 12 people" and I say "no, it was 14", then that's not criticism. We can consider the perspective that this one tweet is part of a bigger narrative... but then she didn't "conclude" that with NotTodaySatan.
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 11:52
1
1
@DavePhD "Yes, it's part of a bigger narrative." which isn't "concluded" with #NotTodaySatan - that's my point for this perspective.
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 12:21
@DavePhD "Yes, it's part of a bigger narrative." which isn't "concluded" with #NotTodaySatan - that's my point for this perspective.
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 12:21
|
show 1 more comment
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
"Not Today Satan" is a common phrase used by religious people that means "I'm not going to brought down today". While there is clearly an effort to make it out as if Rep. Omar is saying that America is Satan, that is clearly not what this phrase means.
If you look for other tweets that use that hashtag, once you scroll down past the manufactured right-wing outrage, you'll see tweets like:
work drags lol #nottodaysatan
Almost accidentally read an Endgame spoiler #NOTTODAYSATAN
When life isn't the way you hoped, you change it and make it what you need. Work is hard, but providing for myself and my husband is more important than the trivial bitches. #nottodaysatan pic.twitter.com/3i39KznNIW
when I was 14 they predicted a valve replacement at 30. Today was my annual check up, and a bitch gets to keep her valve! What’s good heart disease!? #nottodaysatan
Already know some type of blessing is on the way when the energy vampire ex pops up. Demons can smell happiness. #Nottodaysatan 🙅🏽♀️
No Anti-American sentiment there!
Some more evidence that this is not some sort of secret terrorist hashtag:
From CBN News (The Christian Perspective): 'Not Today Satan': How to Respond to Hollywood Haters and Their War on Christians
From Boundless a "Focus on the Family community for Christian young adults": Not Today, Satan: Battling the Enemy’s Lies
A "Not Today Satan" shirt from ChristianBook.com with the "Witness message": "Not Today Satan. Submit Yourselves Therefore To God. Resist The Devil, And He Will flee From You. James 4:7."
A "Not Today Satan" Lanyard from LifeWay Christian Resources
Etsy, not known as hotbed for Islamist Extremism, has 3284 items with that slogan on it, often paired with a cross.
Urban Dictionary attributes its mainstream popularity to Bianca Del Rio, the winner of Season 6 of RuPaul's Drag Race
There are even memes that use it
As for why she might have said that, the tweet you linked to is a direct reply to another tweet by @j_w_84 which I've reproduced below:
In that tweet, Joshua claims that the that the worst terrorist attack in Somalia was the Battle of Mogadishu where 19 Americans were killed, not the then recent terrorist attack (referenced in the original tweet by Al Franken) where 230 Somalis were killed. The only way that makes sense is if you completely devalue the lives of Somalis, both those killed in the recent terrorist attack (to say that 19 dead is worse than 230 dead) and those killed in the fighting in Mogadishu (U.S. special representative to Somalia Robert B. Oakley estimated that there were 1500-2000 civilian casualties due to the reality of fighting a pitched battle in a crowded city).
It's this casually racist attitude from Joshua, which holds that only American lives matter, that Rep. Omar is referring to: just like heart disease, boring work, or Avengers spoilers, the racist attitudes of some will not bring her down and stop the important work of fighting against it.
answered Apr 25 at 21:08
divibisandivibisan
1,940927
1
'is a common phrase' are you sure about that? It doesn't show up in Google's Ngram and it's listed by Urban Dictionary as a quote from someone on RuPaul's Drag Race. Do you have references of its use prior to that show?
– JJJ
Apr 25 at 21:13
3
@JJJ I'm amazed I can't find any more detail, but at least anecdotally I can say I've heard that phrase often enough as far back as between 2008-2012
– Gramatik
Apr 25 at 21:23
15
Its seem even more curious to classify the (1993) Battle of Mogadishu as a "terrorist attack" in the first place, since it appears that the US forces (with allies) were the ones attacking. I can imagine some people being ready to call the US "terrorists", but not the same people that would count only US casualties. And if it was a terrorist attack then surely 1500-2000 is more than 230 ...
– Henning Makholm
Apr 26 at 0:10
4
@JJJ The 1999 movie Toy Story 2 contains a reference to this phrase ('Not today, Zurg') and the 1994 movie Ace Ventura contains it verbatim - it's old and well established, I'd say.
– samiles
Apr 26 at 8:48
3
@JJJ The Toy Story quote definitely refers to that phrase, IMO, as I said, "references". And you're quite right about Ace Ventura, I was muddled with something else. There's numerous uses of it long before the Ru Paul suggestion above.
– samiles
Apr 26 at 9:35
|
show 4 more comments
Probably as a humorous way of saying "you're not going to get one past me."
This seems to be a recent but widespread phrase. We can see many humorous books with this phrase in their title.
The original use was seemingly literal, mainly coming from Christians metaphorically telling Satan that he wouldn't win.
When the computers act up I speak "In the name of Jesus not today Satan.
My Book is My Story: Surrendering My Journey to the Holy Spirit (2013)
Or
When I sense him using my rough day to steal my joy, he's crossing a line and I tell him "Not today, Satan." I even have T-shirt that says it in big, white, block letters.
The Year of Living Happy: Finding Contentment and Connection in a Crazy World (2018)
However, it seems to have mutated due to overuse (e.g., people would say "Not today, Satan" when their computers acted up or they were having a bad day). While the original phrase referenced actually catching Satan trying to ruin one's life and refusing to allow this, the broad version seems to refer to catching anyone in the act and refusing to allow them to go forward, particularly in relation to not letting someone ruin one's day.
answered Apr 25 at 21:20
Obie 2.0Obie 2.0
2,9471026
was "not today Satan" still associated with Christians when she tweeted this, or had it already become secularized?
– DavePhD
Apr 26 at 11:49
1
Check the other answer, but I'd say it had broad secular usage. Christians have still continued to use it in the Christian usage until the present day, though.
– Obie 2.0
Apr 26 at 11:51
add a comment |
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
"Not Today Satan" is a common phrase used by religious people that means "I'm not going to brought down today". While there is clearly an effort to make it out as if Rep. Omar is saying that America is Satan, that is clearly not what this phrase means.
If you look for other tweets that use that hashtag, once you scroll down past the manufactured right-wing outrage, you'll see tweets like:
work drags lol #nottodaysatan
Almost accidentally read an Endgame spoiler #NOTTODAYSATAN
When life isn't the way you hoped, you change it and make it what you need. Work is hard, but providing for myself and my husband is more important than the trivial bitches. #nottodaysatan pic.twitter.com/3i39KznNIW
when I was 14 they predicted a valve replacement at 30. Today was my annual check up, and a bitch gets to keep her valve! What’s good heart disease!? #nottodaysatan
Already know some type of blessing is on the way when the energy vampire ex pops up. Demons can smell happiness. #Nottodaysatan 🙅🏽♀️
No Anti-American sentiment there!
Some more evidence that this is not some sort of secret terrorist hashtag:
From CBN News (The Christian Perspective): 'Not Today Satan': How to Respond to Hollywood Haters and Their War on Christians
From Boundless a "Focus on the Family community for Christian young adults": Not Today, Satan: Battling the Enemy’s Lies
A "Not Today Satan" shirt from ChristianBook.com with the "Witness message": "Not Today Satan. Submit Yourselves Therefore To God. Resist The Devil, And He Will flee From You. James 4:7."
A "Not Today Satan" Lanyard from LifeWay Christian Resources
Etsy, not known as hotbed for Islamist Extremism, has 3284 items with that slogan on it, often paired with a cross.
Urban Dictionary attributes its mainstream popularity to Bianca Del Rio, the winner of Season 6 of RuPaul's Drag Race
There are even memes that use it
As for why she might have said that, the tweet you linked to is a direct reply to another tweet by @j_w_84 which I've reproduced below:
In that tweet, Joshua claims that the that the worst terrorist attack in Somalia was the Battle of Mogadishu where 19 Americans were killed, not the then recent terrorist attack (referenced in the original tweet by Al Franken) where 230 Somalis were killed. The only way that makes sense is if you completely devalue the lives of Somalis, both those killed in the recent terrorist attack (to say that 19 dead is worse than 230 dead) and those killed in the fighting in Mogadishu (U.S. special representative to Somalia Robert B. Oakley estimated that there were 1500-2000 civilian casualties due to the reality of fighting a pitched battle in a crowded city).
It's this casually racist attitude from Joshua, which holds that only American lives matter, that Rep. Omar is referring to: just like heart disease, boring work, or Avengers spoilers, the racist attitudes of some will not bring her down and stop the important work of fighting against it.
answered Apr 25 at 21:08
divibisandivibisan
1,940927
1
'is a common phrase' are you sure about that? It doesn't show up in Google's Ngram and it's listed by Urban Dictionary as a quote from someone on RuPaul's Drag Race. Do you have references of its use prior to that show?
– JJJ
Apr 25 at 21:13
3
@JJJ I'm amazed I can't find any more detail, but at least anecdotally I can say I've heard that phrase often enough as far back as between 2008-2012
– Gramatik
Apr 25 at 21:23
15
Its seem even more curious to classify the (1993) Battle of Mogadishu as a "terrorist attack" in the first place, since it appears that the US forces (with allies) were the ones attacking. I can imagine some people being ready to call the US "terrorists", but not the same people that would count only US casualties. And if it was a terrorist attack then surely 1500-2000 is more than 230 ...
– Henning Makholm
Apr 26 at 0:10
4
@JJJ The 1999 movie Toy Story 2 contains a reference to this phrase ('Not today, Zurg') and the 1994 movie Ace Ventura contains it verbatim - it's old and well established, I'd say.
– samiles
Apr 26 at 8:48
3
@JJJ The Toy Story quote definitely refers to that phrase, IMO, as I said, "references". And you're quite right about Ace Ventura, I was muddled with something else. There's numerous uses of it long before the Ru Paul suggestion above.
– samiles
Apr 26 at 9:35
|
show 4 more comments
"Not Today Satan" is a common phrase used by religious people that means "I'm not going to brought down today". While there is clearly an effort to make it out as if Rep. Omar is saying that America is Satan, that is clearly not what this phrase means.
If you look for other tweets that use that hashtag, once you scroll down past the manufactured right-wing outrage, you'll see tweets like:
work drags lol #nottodaysatan
Almost accidentally read an Endgame spoiler #NOTTODAYSATAN
When life isn't the way you hoped, you change it and make it what you need. Work is hard, but providing for myself and my husband is more important than the trivial bitches. #nottodaysatan pic.twitter.com/3i39KznNIW
when I was 14 they predicted a valve replacement at 30. Today was my annual check up, and a bitch gets to keep her valve! What’s good heart disease!? #nottodaysatan
Already know some type of blessing is on the way when the energy vampire ex pops up. Demons can smell happiness. #Nottodaysatan 🙅🏽♀️
No Anti-American sentiment there!
Some more evidence that this is not some sort of secret terrorist hashtag:
From CBN News (The Christian Perspective): 'Not Today Satan': How to Respond to Hollywood Haters and Their War on Christians
From Boundless a "Focus on the Family community for Christian young adults": Not Today, Satan: Battling the Enemy’s Lies
A "Not Today Satan" shirt from ChristianBook.com with the "Witness message": "Not Today Satan. Submit Yourselves Therefore To God. Resist The Devil, And He Will flee From You. James 4:7."
A "Not Today Satan" Lanyard from LifeWay Christian Resources
Etsy, not known as hotbed for Islamist Extremism, has 3284 items with that slogan on it, often paired with a cross.
Urban Dictionary attributes its mainstream popularity to Bianca Del Rio, the winner of Season 6 of RuPaul's Drag Race
There are even memes that use it
As for why she might have said that, the tweet you linked to is a direct reply to another tweet by @j_w_84 which I've reproduced below:
In that tweet, Joshua claims that the that the worst terrorist attack in Somalia was the Battle of Mogadishu where 19 Americans were killed, not the then recent terrorist attack (referenced in the original tweet by Al Franken) where 230 Somalis were killed. The only way that makes sense is if you completely devalue the lives of Somalis, both those killed in the recent terrorist attack (to say that 19 dead is worse than 230 dead) and those killed in the fighting in Mogadishu (U.S. special representative to Somalia Robert B. Oakley estimated that there were 1500-2000 civilian casualties due to the reality of fighting a pitched battle in a crowded city).
It's this casually racist attitude from Joshua, which holds that only American lives matter, that Rep. Omar is referring to: just like heart disease, boring work, or Avengers spoilers, the racist attitudes of some will not bring her down and stop the important work of fighting against it.
answered Apr 25 at 21:08
divibisandivibisan
1,940927
1
'is a common phrase' are you sure about that? It doesn't show up in Google's Ngram and it's listed by Urban Dictionary as a quote from someone on RuPaul's Drag Race. Do you have references of its use prior to that show?
– JJJ
Apr 25 at 21:13
3
@JJJ I'm amazed I can't find any more detail, but at least anecdotally I can say I've heard that phrase often enough as far back as between 2008-2012
– Gramatik
Apr 25 at 21:23
15
Its seem even more curious to classify the (1993) Battle of Mogadishu as a "terrorist attack" in the first place, since it appears that the US forces (with allies) were the ones attacking. I can imagine some people being ready to call the US "terrorists", but not the same people that would count only US casualties. And if it was a terrorist attack then surely 1500-2000 is more than 230 ...
– Henning Makholm
Apr 26 at 0:10
4
@JJJ The 1999 movie Toy Story 2 contains a reference to this phrase ('Not today, Zurg') and the 1994 movie Ace Ventura contains it verbatim - it's old and well established, I'd say.
– samiles
Apr 26 at 8:48
3
@JJJ The Toy Story quote definitely refers to that phrase, IMO, as I said, "references". And you're quite right about Ace Ventura, I was muddled with something else. There's numerous uses of it long before the Ru Paul suggestion above.
– samiles
Apr 26 at 9:35
|
show 4 more comments
"Not Today Satan" is a common phrase used by religious people that means "I'm not going to brought down today". While there is clearly an effort to make it out as if Rep. Omar is saying that America is Satan, that is clearly not what this phrase means.
If you look for other tweets that use that hashtag, once you scroll down past the manufactured right-wing outrage, you'll see tweets like:
work drags lol #nottodaysatan
Almost accidentally read an Endgame spoiler #NOTTODAYSATAN
When life isn't the way you hoped, you change it and make it what you need. Work is hard, but providing for myself and my husband is more important than the trivial bitches. #nottodaysatan pic.twitter.com/3i39KznNIW
when I was 14 they predicted a valve replacement at 30. Today was my annual check up, and a bitch gets to keep her valve! What’s good heart disease!? #nottodaysatan
Already know some type of blessing is on the way when the energy vampire ex pops up. Demons can smell happiness. #Nottodaysatan 🙅🏽♀️
No Anti-American sentiment there!
Some more evidence that this is not some sort of secret terrorist hashtag:
From CBN News (The Christian Perspective): 'Not Today Satan': How to Respond to Hollywood Haters and Their War on Christians
From Boundless a "Focus on the Family community for Christian young adults": Not Today, Satan: Battling the Enemy’s Lies
A "Not Today Satan" shirt from ChristianBook.com with the "Witness message": "Not Today Satan. Submit Yourselves Therefore To God. Resist The Devil, And He Will flee From You. James 4:7."
A "Not Today Satan" Lanyard from LifeWay Christian Resources
Etsy, not known as hotbed for Islamist Extremism, has 3284 items with that slogan on it, often paired with a cross.
Urban Dictionary attributes its mainstream popularity to Bianca Del Rio, the winner of Season 6 of RuPaul's Drag Race
There are even memes that use it
As for why she might have said that, the tweet you linked to is a direct reply to another tweet by @j_w_84 which I've reproduced below:
In that tweet, Joshua claims that the that the worst terrorist attack in Somalia was the Battle of Mogadishu where 19 Americans were killed, not the then recent terrorist attack (referenced in the original tweet by Al Franken) where 230 Somalis were killed. The only way that makes sense is if you completely devalue the lives of Somalis, both those killed in the recent terrorist attack (to say that 19 dead is worse than 230 dead) and those killed in the fighting in Mogadishu (U.S. special representative to Somalia Robert B. Oakley estimated that there were 1500-2000 civilian casualties due to the reality of fighting a pitched battle in a crowded city).
It's this casually racist attitude from Joshua, which holds that only American lives matter, that Rep. Omar is referring to: just like heart disease, boring work, or Avengers spoilers, the racist attitudes of some will not bring her down and stop the important work of fighting against it.
answered Apr 25 at 21:08
divibisandivibisan
1,940927
"Not Today Satan" is a common phrase used by religious people that means "I'm not going to brought down today". While there is clearly an effort to make it out as if Rep. Omar is saying that America is Satan, that is clearly not what this phrase means.
If you look for other tweets that use that hashtag, once you scroll down past the manufactured right-wing outrage, you'll see tweets like:
work drags lol #nottodaysatan
Almost accidentally read an Endgame spoiler #NOTTODAYSATAN
When life isn't the way you hoped, you change it and make it what you need. Work is hard, but providing for myself and my husband is more important than the trivial bitches. #nottodaysatan pic.twitter.com/3i39KznNIW
when I was 14 they predicted a valve replacement at 30. Today was my annual check up, and a bitch gets to keep her valve! What’s good heart disease!? #nottodaysatan
Already know some type of blessing is on the way when the energy vampire ex pops up. Demons can smell happiness. #Nottodaysatan 🙅🏽♀️
No Anti-American sentiment there!
Some more evidence that this is not some sort of secret terrorist hashtag:
From CBN News (The Christian Perspective): 'Not Today Satan': How to Respond to Hollywood Haters and Their War on Christians
From Boundless a "Focus on the Family community for Christian young adults": Not Today, Satan: Battling the Enemy’s Lies
A "Not Today Satan" shirt from ChristianBook.com with the "Witness message": "Not Today Satan. Submit Yourselves Therefore To God. Resist The Devil, And He Will flee From You. James 4:7."
A "Not Today Satan" Lanyard from LifeWay Christian Resources
Etsy, not known as hotbed for Islamist Extremism, has 3284 items with that slogan on it, often paired with a cross.
Urban Dictionary attributes its mainstream popularity to Bianca Del Rio, the winner of Season 6 of RuPaul's Drag Race
There are even memes that use it
As for why she might have said that, the tweet you linked to is a direct reply to another tweet by @j_w_84 which I've reproduced below:
In that tweet, Joshua claims that the that the worst terrorist attack in Somalia was the Battle of Mogadishu where 19 Americans were killed, not the then recent terrorist attack (referenced in the original tweet by Al Franken) where 230 Somalis were killed. The only way that makes sense is if you completely devalue the lives of Somalis, both those killed in the recent terrorist attack (to say that 19 dead is worse than 230 dead) and those killed in the fighting in Mogadishu (U.S. special representative to Somalia Robert B. Oakley estimated that there were 1500-2000 civilian casualties due to the reality of fighting a pitched battle in a crowded city).
It's this casually racist attitude from Joshua, which holds that only American lives matter, that Rep. Omar is referring to: just like heart disease, boring work, or Avengers spoilers, the racist attitudes of some will not bring her down and stop the important work of fighting against it.
answered Apr 25 at 21:08
divibisandivibisan
1,940927
edited Apr 25 at 21:21
answered Apr 25 at 21:08
divibisandivibisan
1,940927
answered Apr 25 at 21:08
divibisandivibisan
1,940927
answered Apr 25 at 21:08
divibisandivibisan
1,940927
1,940927
1
'is a common phrase' are you sure about that? It doesn't show up in Google's Ngram and it's listed by Urban Dictionary as a quote from someone on RuPaul's Drag Race. Do you have references of its use prior to that show?
– JJJ
Apr 25 at 21:13
3
@JJJ I'm amazed I can't find any more detail, but at least anecdotally I can say I've heard that phrase often enough as far back as between 2008-2012
– Gramatik
Apr 25 at 21:23
15
Its seem even more curious to classify the (1993) Battle of Mogadishu as a "terrorist attack" in the first place, since it appears that the US forces (with allies) were the ones attacking. I can imagine some people being ready to call the US "terrorists", but not the same people that would count only US casualties. And if it was a terrorist attack then surely 1500-2000 is more than 230 ...
– Henning Makholm
Apr 26 at 0:10
4
@JJJ The 1999 movie Toy Story 2 contains a reference to this phrase ('Not today, Zurg') and the 1994 movie Ace Ventura contains it verbatim - it's old and well established, I'd say.
– samiles
Apr 26 at 8:48
3
@JJJ The Toy Story quote definitely refers to that phrase, IMO, as I said, "references". And you're quite right about Ace Ventura, I was muddled with something else. There's numerous uses of it long before the Ru Paul suggestion above.
– samiles
Apr 26 at 9:35
|
show 4 more comments
1
'is a common phrase' are you sure about that? It doesn't show up in Google's Ngram and it's listed by Urban Dictionary as a quote from someone on RuPaul's Drag Race. Do you have references of its use prior to that show?
– JJJ
Apr 25 at 21:13
3
@JJJ I'm amazed I can't find any more detail, but at least anecdotally I can say I've heard that phrase often enough as far back as between 2008-2012
– Gramatik
Apr 25 at 21:23
15
Its seem even more curious to classify the (1993) Battle of Mogadishu as a "terrorist attack" in the first place, since it appears that the US forces (with allies) were the ones attacking. I can imagine some people being ready to call the US "terrorists", but not the same people that would count only US casualties. And if it was a terrorist attack then surely 1500-2000 is more than 230 ...
– Henning Makholm
Apr 26 at 0:10
4
@JJJ The 1999 movie Toy Story 2 contains a reference to this phrase ('Not today, Zurg') and the 1994 movie Ace Ventura contains it verbatim - it's old and well established, I'd say.
– samiles
Apr 26 at 8:48
3
@JJJ The Toy Story quote definitely refers to that phrase, IMO, as I said, "references". And you're quite right about Ace Ventura, I was muddled with something else. There's numerous uses of it long before the Ru Paul suggestion above.
– samiles
Apr 26 at 9:35
1
1
'is a common phrase' are you sure about that? It doesn't show up in Google's Ngram and it's listed by Urban Dictionary as a quote from someone on RuPaul's Drag Race. Do you have references of its use prior to that show?
– JJJ
Apr 25 at 21:13
'is a common phrase' are you sure about that? It doesn't show up in Google's Ngram and it's listed by Urban Dictionary as a quote from someone on RuPaul's Drag Race. Do you have references of its use prior to that show?
– JJJ
Apr 25 at 21:13
3
3
@JJJ I'm amazed I can't find any more detail, but at least anecdotally I can say I've heard that phrase often enough as far back as between 2008-2012
– Gramatik
Apr 25 at 21:23
@JJJ I'm amazed I can't find any more detail, but at least anecdotally I can say I've heard that phrase often enough as far back as between 2008-2012
– Gramatik
Apr 25 at 21:23
15
15
Its seem even more curious to classify the (1993) Battle of Mogadishu as a "terrorist attack" in the first place, since it appears that the US forces (with allies) were the ones attacking. I can imagine some people being ready to call the US "terrorists", but not the same people that would count only US casualties. And if it was a terrorist attack then surely 1500-2000 is more than 230 ...
– Henning Makholm
Apr 26 at 0:10
Its seem even more curious to classify the (1993) Battle of Mogadishu as a "terrorist attack" in the first place, since it appears that the US forces (with allies) were the ones attacking. I can imagine some people being ready to call the US "terrorists", but not the same people that would count only US casualties. And if it was a terrorist attack then surely 1500-2000 is more than 230 ...
– Henning Makholm
Apr 26 at 0:10
4
4
@JJJ The 1999 movie Toy Story 2 contains a reference to this phrase ('Not today, Zurg') and the 1994 movie Ace Ventura contains it verbatim - it's old and well established, I'd say.
– samiles
Apr 26 at 8:48
@JJJ The 1999 movie Toy Story 2 contains a reference to this phrase ('Not today, Zurg') and the 1994 movie Ace Ventura contains it verbatim - it's old and well established, I'd say.
– samiles
Apr 26 at 8:48
3
3
@JJJ The Toy Story quote definitely refers to that phrase, IMO, as I said, "references". And you're quite right about Ace Ventura, I was muddled with something else. There's numerous uses of it long before the Ru Paul suggestion above.
– samiles
Apr 26 at 9:35
@JJJ The Toy Story quote definitely refers to that phrase, IMO, as I said, "references". And you're quite right about Ace Ventura, I was muddled with something else. There's numerous uses of it long before the Ru Paul suggestion above.
– samiles
Apr 26 at 9:35
|
show 4 more comments
Probably as a humorous way of saying "you're not going to get one past me."
This seems to be a recent but widespread phrase. We can see many humorous books with this phrase in their title.
The original use was seemingly literal, mainly coming from Christians metaphorically telling Satan that he wouldn't win.
When the computers act up I speak "In the name of Jesus not today Satan.
My Book is My Story: Surrendering My Journey to the Holy Spirit (2013)
Or
When I sense him using my rough day to steal my joy, he's crossing a line and I tell him "Not today, Satan." I even have T-shirt that says it in big, white, block letters.
The Year of Living Happy: Finding Contentment and Connection in a Crazy World (2018)
However, it seems to have mutated due to overuse (e.g., people would say "Not today, Satan" when their computers acted up or they were having a bad day). While the original phrase referenced actually catching Satan trying to ruin one's life and refusing to allow this, the broad version seems to refer to catching anyone in the act and refusing to allow them to go forward, particularly in relation to not letting someone ruin one's day.
answered Apr 25 at 21:20
Obie 2.0Obie 2.0
2,9471026
was "not today Satan" still associated with Christians when she tweeted this, or had it already become secularized?
– DavePhD
Apr 26 at 11:49
1
Check the other answer, but I'd say it had broad secular usage. Christians have still continued to use it in the Christian usage until the present day, though.
– Obie 2.0
Apr 26 at 11:51
add a comment |
Probably as a humorous way of saying "you're not going to get one past me."
This seems to be a recent but widespread phrase. We can see many humorous books with this phrase in their title.
The original use was seemingly literal, mainly coming from Christians metaphorically telling Satan that he wouldn't win.
When the computers act up I speak "In the name of Jesus not today Satan.
My Book is My Story: Surrendering My Journey to the Holy Spirit (2013)
Or
When I sense him using my rough day to steal my joy, he's crossing a line and I tell him "Not today, Satan." I even have T-shirt that says it in big, white, block letters.
The Year of Living Happy: Finding Contentment and Connection in a Crazy World (2018)
However, it seems to have mutated due to overuse (e.g., people would say "Not today, Satan" when their computers acted up or they were having a bad day). While the original phrase referenced actually catching Satan trying to ruin one's life and refusing to allow this, the broad version seems to refer to catching anyone in the act and refusing to allow them to go forward, particularly in relation to not letting someone ruin one's day.
answered Apr 25 at 21:20
Obie 2.0Obie 2.0
2,9471026
was "not today Satan" still associated with Christians when she tweeted this, or had it already become secularized?
– DavePhD
Apr 26 at 11:49
1
Check the other answer, but I'd say it had broad secular usage. Christians have still continued to use it in the Christian usage until the present day, though.
– Obie 2.0
Apr 26 at 11:51
add a comment |
Probably as a humorous way of saying "you're not going to get one past me."
This seems to be a recent but widespread phrase. We can see many humorous books with this phrase in their title.
The original use was seemingly literal, mainly coming from Christians metaphorically telling Satan that he wouldn't win.
When the computers act up I speak "In the name of Jesus not today Satan.
My Book is My Story: Surrendering My Journey to the Holy Spirit (2013)
Or
When I sense him using my rough day to steal my joy, he's crossing a line and I tell him "Not today, Satan." I even have T-shirt that says it in big, white, block letters.
The Year of Living Happy: Finding Contentment and Connection in a Crazy World (2018)
However, it seems to have mutated due to overuse (e.g., people would say "Not today, Satan" when their computers acted up or they were having a bad day). While the original phrase referenced actually catching Satan trying to ruin one's life and refusing to allow this, the broad version seems to refer to catching anyone in the act and refusing to allow them to go forward, particularly in relation to not letting someone ruin one's day.
answered Apr 25 at 21:20
Obie 2.0Obie 2.0
2,9471026
Probably as a humorous way of saying "you're not going to get one past me."
This seems to be a recent but widespread phrase. We can see many humorous books with this phrase in their title.
The original use was seemingly literal, mainly coming from Christians metaphorically telling Satan that he wouldn't win.
When the computers act up I speak "In the name of Jesus not today Satan.
My Book is My Story: Surrendering My Journey to the Holy Spirit (2013)
Or
When I sense him using my rough day to steal my joy, he's crossing a line and I tell him "Not today, Satan." I even have T-shirt that says it in big, white, block letters.
The Year of Living Happy: Finding Contentment and Connection in a Crazy World (2018)
However, it seems to have mutated due to overuse (e.g., people would say "Not today, Satan" when their computers acted up or they were having a bad day). While the original phrase referenced actually catching Satan trying to ruin one's life and refusing to allow this, the broad version seems to refer to catching anyone in the act and refusing to allow them to go forward, particularly in relation to not letting someone ruin one's day.
answered Apr 25 at 21:20
Obie 2.0Obie 2.0
2,9471026
edited Apr 25 at 21:31
answered Apr 25 at 21:20
Obie 2.0Obie 2.0
2,9471026
answered Apr 25 at 21:20
Obie 2.0Obie 2.0
2,9471026
answered Apr 25 at 21:20
Obie 2.0Obie 2.0
2,9471026
2,9471026
was "not today Satan" still associated with Christians when she tweeted this, or had it already become secularized?
– DavePhD
Apr 26 at 11:49
1
Check the other answer, but I'd say it had broad secular usage. Christians have still continued to use it in the Christian usage until the present day, though.
– Obie 2.0
Apr 26 at 11:51
add a comment |
was "not today Satan" still associated with Christians when she tweeted this, or had it already become secularized?
– DavePhD
Apr 26 at 11:49
1
Check the other answer, but I'd say it had broad secular usage. Christians have still continued to use it in the Christian usage until the present day, though.
– Obie 2.0
Apr 26 at 11:51
was "not today Satan" still associated with Christians when she tweeted this, or had it already become secularized?
– DavePhD
Apr 26 at 11:49
was "not today Satan" still associated with Christians when she tweeted this, or had it already become secularized?
– DavePhD
Apr 26 at 11:49
1
1
Check the other answer, but I'd say it had broad secular usage. Christians have still continued to use it in the Christian usage until the present day, though.
– Obie 2.0
Apr 26 at 11:51
Check the other answer, but I'd say it had broad secular usage. Christians have still continued to use it in the Christian usage until the present day, though.
– Obie 2.0
Apr 26 at 11:51
add a comment |
It looks like a contemporaneous meme given that the tweet was from 2017. There are multiple reads of what she could be saying though.
– hszmv
Apr 25 at 21:03
5
Where does the "her criticism of US troops" in the title come from? The tweet you link is concerned with correcting an incredibly racist statement. I don't see how it makes any special effort to criticize US troops. It does state that US troops kill people - but as an answer to somebody implying they didn't, you can hardly consider that "criticism".
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 11:34
@R.Schmitz I think it's clear that she is criticizing the number of Somalis killed. Whether she blames Clinton, or the troops actually in Somalia, or the chain of command somewhere in between, I don't know.
– DavePhD
Apr 26 at 11:43
3
@DavePhD With all due respect, no it's not. Just saying "US troops kill so-and-so many people" is not criticism, it's a statistic. Now, "killing people" is not a good thing, but if somebody says "they killed 12 people" and I say "no, it was 14", then that's not criticism. We can consider the perspective that this one tweet is part of a bigger narrative... but then she didn't "conclude" that with NotTodaySatan.
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 11:52
1
@DavePhD "Yes, it's part of a bigger narrative." which isn't "concluded" with #NotTodaySatan - that's my point for this perspective.
– R. Schmitz
Apr 26 at 12:21